TL;DR: Quick Answer
To sell business insurance by phone, lead with safety, not price. Ask what the owner has now and what a bad day would cost them, compare cover honestly side by side without running down their insurer, and aim for a booked review meeting rather than a sale on the first call.
In insurance, Safety counts 4 out of 10, then Price 2 and Ease 2. A cover that looks cheaper at R1,500 a month means little until the owner feels sure about it.
Ask two questions early: "What do you have in place today?" and "If your worst day happened this year, what would it cost you?"
Check every line in this article with the person responsible for compliance in your business, then practise it out loud on the ShiftMate sales call simulator.
If you want to know how to sell business insurance by phone, start with one idea: the owner on the other end is not shopping for a premium, they are deciding whether they can trust you with a worry. This article teaches one step of Mike Steenkamp's six value principles method , the step called "Show it's safe", and builds the rest of the call around it.
It is written for people who sell, and for the managers who coach them, in South Africa. It covers selling business insurance from the first thirty seconds to the booked review meeting, with word-for-word lines you can adapt. One thing before we start: this article does not set out any rules. What you may say, how you may say it and what has to be recorded or confirmed are questions for your own business. Please check every line here with the person responsible for compliance where you work before you use it.
Key Takeaways
For insurance the method weights Safety at 4 out of 10, with Price at 2 and Ease at 2. Safety is a gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure.
Open with who you are, why you are calling and why it matters to them. "Why it matters to them" is worth 3 of the 10 opening points.
On ShiftMate Sim Studio your team can practise these calls out loud on AI buyers, and each practice call ends with one thing to fix first.
How to sell business insurance: start with safety, not price
The first answer to how to sell business insurance is the weighting. Mike Steenkamp's method lists six reasons a business buys: Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume and Price. How much each one counts depends on the industry. For insurance the figures, out of 10, are Safety 4, Quality 1, Ease 2, Speed 1, Volume 0 and Price 2.
Insurance: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)
Safety
4
Quality
1
Ease
2
Speed
1
Volume
0
Price
2
Safety gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is safe.
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
Read that chart as a call plan. Safety is worth twice what Price is worth, and Insurance is marked a "safety gate" in the method. A gate means nothing else counts until the buyer is sure the new arrangement is at least as safe as what they have now. A lower price, a smoother process or a quicker quote all land on deaf ears if the owner is still asking, quietly, "Will this actually look after me when it matters?"
That is also why the research on business buyers fits. Eric Almquist, Jamie Cleghorn and Lori Sherer, writing in the Harvard Business Review, found that business buyers weigh up to 40 "elements of value", from basics such as an acceptable price, through ease of doing business, to personal concerns such as reduced anxiety. You can read it in "The B2B Elements of Value" . A business owner buying cover is buying less anxiety, and price is only one part of that.
What "safe" means to the owner on the phone
You will not decide what safe means. The owner will. For one person it is knowing a claim will be taken seriously. For another it is knowing who to phone on a Saturday. For another it is not being surprised by what is left out. Your job on the call is to find out which one it is and show, using their own words, that you took it seriously.
Never promise what a policy does. Every example in this article ends with the same instruction: check your own policy wording. What a given product covers, excludes or pays is written in that product's documents, not in your pitch. If you are not sure what a line means, stop and ask the person responsible for compliance in your business before you say it to a customer.
Why the "convince me" mindset matters
Step 3 of the method is "Remember the default answer is no." The owner is thinking "convince me". In insurance that default is stronger, because the old arrangement has a track record and yours does not. Surveys back up the mood. In a Gartner survey of B2B buyers, 73% said they actively avoid suppliers who send irrelevant outreach. The survey was mostly of buyers in other markets, so treat it as a pointer, not a South African figure.
If you are selling business insurance, "relevant" means you know something about their business before you dial and you say it in the first thirty seconds.
What should you say in the first 30 seconds?
Say who you are, your company, what the call is about, how you got their details, what you want, and why it matters to them. That is the opening in step 2 of the method, "Earn the right to talk", and it can be scored out of 10.
The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)
Who you are
1
Your company
1
What your company does (must be said)
0
What the call is about
2
How you got their details
1
What you want from this call
2
Why it matters to them
3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
Look at where the points sit. "What your company does" earns 0 on its own. It has to be said, but it buys you nothing. "Why it matters to them" is worth 3, the most of any part. Seven out of ten is a good opening, and a tough buyer needs eight or nine. With insurance, the "how you got their details" point is not a formality. A business owner who feels watched will not listen, so be plain about where you found them. Whatever you say there, check it with the person responsible for compliance in your business first.
A made-up opening call
Here is a made-up example. Grant is a cover adviser at an invented company, Sunbird Business Cover, calling Priya, who owns a small bakery supply company called Kloof Bakehouse Supplies. Every name and figure here is invented.
Grant: "Hi Priya, it's Grant Fourie from Sunbird Business Cover. I'm calling about the cover on your delivery vehicles and stock. I found your business through the supplier list on your trade association's website, so I'm calling you specifically, not working through a random list. I'd like two minutes to ask what you have in place today and what a bad day would cost you. If it's not useful, I'll thank you and go. Is now an okay time?"
Count the points. Who he is: 1. His company: 1. What the call is about: 2. How he got her details: 1. What he wants: 2. Why it matters to her ("what a bad day would cost you"): partly there, but not yet 3, because he has not tied it to her business. Strong opening, one gap. A tighter version of the last part: "I'm asking because bakeries that carry their own stock and drivers tend to feel a bad day in one week, not one year." Only say something like that if your compliance person is happy with it, and only if it is true for the business in front of you.
What should you ask to find out what a bad day would cost?
Ask what they have now, how they feel about it, and what a bad day would cost them in rand. Those three questions are the heart of selling business insurance by phone. They move the call from your product to their risk, and they give you the number you need later when you compare cover.
These questions are the core of how to sell business insurance well, and they sit inside step 4 of the method, "Prove value with the six value principles", which asks you to compare with what they use now and back it with a number or an example. Our article on sales discovery questions that expose hidden cost goes deeper on the technique.
Six questions you can adapt
"What do you have in place today?" You are listening for what they know about their own cover. Many owners know the monthly amount and little else. Do not correct them. Write it down.
"When did someone last sit down with you and go through it?" A long gap is not a reason to criticise. It is a reason to offer a review.
"Has anything changed in the business since then?" New premises, new vehicles, more staff, more stock. A change in their business is also a real reason to act now, which is step 6 of the method.
"If your worst day happened this year, what would it cost you?" Let them answer in rand. If they say "I don't know", say "That's common. Would it help if we worked it out together on the meeting?"
"Who would you phone first?" This tells you whether they trust their current contact.
"What matters most to you if something goes wrong?" This is their definition of safe, in their words.
Listen more than you talk. A meta-analysis in the Journal of Business and Psychology, covering 664 effect sizes, found a correlation of .39 between being seen as a good listener and work outcomes, and a stronger link to relationship quality (.51) than to performance (.36). It is not specific to insurance or to South Africa, but it supports what experienced sellers already know. You can read it in the journal , and our piece on what active listening sounds like in sales shows it in call form.
Turning the answers into a rand number
Suppose Priya says, "If a delivery vehicle was out of action for a month, I would lose about R85,000 in orders and still pay the driver." Repeat it back: "So a month without that vehicle is about R85,000 to you. Have I got that right?" That number is hers. You did not invent it, and you can use it again in the meeting.
Do not turn her number into a promise. Do not say "our cover would pay that." Say "I'd like us to look at the wording together to see how it treats that situation. Please check your own policy wording for how a situation like that is handled." Whether and how any product responds is for the written wording to say.
Who should you speak to, and what do you lead with?
When you work out how to sell business insurance to a company, speak to the person who decides and who carries the risk, and let their role tell you what to lead with. That is step 1 of the method, "Talk to the right person". In a small business that is usually the owner. In a larger one, you may be speaking to finance, office staff or operations, and the lead changes.
What to lead with, by the buyer's role
Buyer's role Lead with Admin and office staff Ease, Speed Finance Price, Safety, Speed Owner Price, Volume Marketing and sales Volume, Quality Operations Speed, Ease, Quality Procurement Price, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
The method's list is clear. An owner cares most about Price and Volume, because it comes out of their pocket and they want the business to grow. Finance leads with Price, Safety and Speed. They see the cost, carry the risk and want things done on time. Admin and office staff lead with Ease and Speed, and never Price, because it is not their money. For insurance, though, the safety gate still sits over all of it. Even an owner who cares about Price first will not move until they are sure the cover is at least as safe as what they have.
Forrester reports that on average 13 people in an organisation are involved in a B2B buying decision, and 86% of B2B purchases stall during the buying process. That is United States and European research on larger firms, so a small South African owner may decide alone. It is still a good reason to ask, "Who else would want to see this before a decision?"
If a gatekeeper answers, our article on how to get past the gatekeeper, honestly covers it. If the person you reach is the financial director, read how to sell to a financial director before the call.
How do you compare cover honestly without running down their insurer?
The honest way to sell business insurance against an incumbent is to put the two arrangements side by side, in the owner's own terms, and talk only about what you can show. Never say the other insurer is bad. This is step 7 of the method, "Agree and redirect": agree with the objection, then redirect to what you do better, and be honest about what switching involves.
You will hear "I'm happy with my current insurer." Treat it as a fair thing to say, not a wall. There is a full article on what to say when a buyer is happy with their current supplier , and another on selling against a competitor without naming them . Here is how it sounds for a made-up insurance call.
Ravi (owner of an invented company, Naidoo Steel Fabricators): "I've been with my insurer for eleven years. I'm happy."
Karin (cover adviser at Orchard Hill Cover, made up): "Eleven years is a long relationship, and that says something good. I'm not asking you to leave anyone. I'd like to put what you have next to what we could offer, line by line, so you can see for yourself. If yours holds up better, you will have lost nothing but half an hour. Can we book thirty minutes next week and bring your current schedule?"
Karin agreed with the objection. She did not say a word against the other insurer. She redirected to a comparison the owner controls.
A side-by-side table you can copy
Bring a simple table to the meeting and fill it in with the owner. The point is to keep the comparison in the owner's hands. Whatever goes in the "what the wording says" column comes from the actual documents, not from you.
Question
What they have now
What you are offering
What good looks like
Worst-day cost (their number)
Owner's figure, in rand
Same figure, same words
The number comes from the owner, not from you
What the wording says
Read from their schedule
Read from the actual wording
Both read out loud, nothing paraphrased into a promise
Who to phone and how fast
Owner's experience
Your named contact
A real name and number, not a call-centre queue promise
Cost over a year
Monthly amount times 12
Monthly amount times 12
Both shown as a yearly rand figure, including anything extra
What switching involves
Nothing
Honest list of steps and time
The owner knows the effort before agreeing
Price, honestly
Price counts 2 out of 10 for insurance, and it still matters. Compare it over a year. A cover at R1,500 a month is R18,000 a year, and one at R1,350 a month is R16,200. The difference of R1,800 is real. It is only worth discussing once the wording has been compared, because a lower number against a different wording is not a like-for-like comparison. Cheaper does not mean better, and the owner should hear you say so. For more, read how to handle price objections without discounting .
Check any line about price or comparison with the person responsible for compliance in your business before you put it in a script. What you may compare, and how, is not something this article can tell you.
How do you book the review meeting when selling business insurance?
The last piece of how to sell business insurance is the ask. Offer to send information and agree a set time to talk again. That is step 8 of the method, "Earn the next step". You do not close on the first call. For commercial insurance sales, a booked review meeting is the win.
The ask should be small, specific and easy to say yes to. "Can I send you a one-page comparison today and phone you on Thursday at 10:00 to go through it?" works better than "Would you like to think about it?" The first has a time on it. The second hands the decision away. Our article on how to book a sales meeting on a first call has more phrasing, and the follow-up call guide covers what happens after.
A made-up closing line
Karin: "Ravi, here is what I heard. A month without your main press would cost you around R120,000, you have not had your cover reviewed in four years, and the business has added two staff since. I'd like to sit with you for thirty minutes, with your current schedule in front of us, and look at the wording side by side. Please check your own policy wording before we meet so we are both working from the real document. Would Thursday at 10:00 or Friday at 14:00 suit you better?"
Notice the choice of two times, the recap in his own numbers and the reminder about the wording. Also notice there is no urgency invented. The real reason to act now is that the business has changed since the last review. That comes from his answers, and it is step 6 of the method: what waiting costs them, a real date or a change in their business.
The copyable call plan
Open with the six parts of the opening checklist. Aim for seven out of ten, more for a tough buyer.
Ask what they have now. Write it down without correcting it.
Ask what a bad day would cost, and get a rand figure in their words.
Find out what safe means to them, in one sentence.
Offer a side-by-side review. Agree with any objection, then redirect.
Name a real reason to act now, if there is one. Never invent one.
Book a time. Send information the same day.
Before every call: check each line with the person responsible for compliance in your business.
Business insurance sales tips for managers
If you manage sellers and want your team to learn how to sell business insurance the same way each time, your job is to make the method easy to repeat and to give feedback that is small enough to use. A Salesforce survey of 7,775 sales professionals found that only 26% said they receive one-to-one coaching at least weekly. That survey is from 2022 and is not South African, but it is a fair prompt to ask how often your own team gets feedback.
Four business insurance sales tips that work for managers:
Score the opening, not the outcome. Use the ten-point opening checklist. Our sales call scorecard template gives you a page to use.
Coach one thing at a time. See sales coaching tips for managers .
Practise out loud, spaced over weeks. A meta-analysis of the spacing effect (Cepeda and colleagues, Psychological Bulletin, 2006) pooled 839 assessments from 317 experiments, and the fact that short, repeated practice beats one long session is one of the more reliable findings in learning research. Read how to practise sales calls so it sticks .
Put the compliance conversation first. Ask your compliance person to read every script before anyone dials, and agree how changes get checked. This article cannot say what applies to you.
If you are new to the whole area, the sales training guide explains all six value principles and the eight steps of the method in order.
What this does not solve
Knowing how to sell business insurance is not the same as knowing what applies to you. This article does not tell you what you may say, what has to be explained to a customer, or what has to be recorded. It does not tell you what any cover includes or leaves out. Those answers live in your business's own guidance and in the written wording of each product, and the person responsible for compliance is the right person to ask. If their view and this article disagree, theirs wins.
It also does not fix a weak product, a bad list or a seller who does not listen. The method gives you a structure for the call. It does not give you trust you have not earned. And it does not remove the "no". Some owners are well served where they are, and a good seller can say, "It sounds like you're in good hands. May I check back next year?" Honesty here is part of safety. The owner has to feel that you would tell them if staying put was the better choice.
Finally, the research cited here comes mostly from the United States and Europe, and from larger companies than many South African owner-managed businesses. Use it as a pointer, and test the lines on your own calls.
How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help
ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. You can try an insurance-style buyer on the sales call simulator and repeat the same call until the opening feels natural. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. For team-wide options, see AI sales training for teams .
Frequently asked questions
How do you start a business insurance sales call?
Say who you are, your company, what the call is about, how you got their details, what you want and why it matters to them. Aim for seven out of ten on the opening checklist. Check the exact wording with the person responsible for compliance in your business before you use it.
What is the most important thing when selling business insurance?
Safety. In the method's weights for insurance, Safety counts 4 out of 10, ahead of Price at 2 and Ease at 2, and it acts as a gate. Show the owner you understand what a bad day would cost them before you talk about price or process.
What questions should I ask a business owner about their cover?
Ask what they have in place today, when it was last reviewed, what has changed in the business, what a bad day would cost in rand, and what matters most to them if something goes wrong. Write down their answers in their own words and repeat them back.
How do I compare cover without criticising their current insurer?
Agree with the objection, then offer a side-by-side review using the owner's own schedule. Compare what the wording says, who they phone and the cost over a year. Do not say anything negative about the other insurer, and tell them to check their own policy wording.
Can I promise a customer that a claim will be paid?
No. Never promise what a policy or product does. What any cover includes, excludes or pays is set out in its written wording, so tell customers to check their own policy wording, and ask the person responsible for compliance in your business how to talk about it.
How do I book a review meeting on the first call?
Offer to send a short comparison and agree a set time to talk again, with a choice of two times. Recap the owner's own numbers first. Do not invent urgency; use a real reason such as a change in their business since the last review.
How do I practise selling business insurance without risking real customers?
Practise out loud on an AI buyer, repeat the call, and look at one thing to fix first each time. The ShiftMate sales call simulator is built for this. Before any real call, check your lines with the person responsible for compliance in your business.
ShiftMate Sim Studio
Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no
Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.
See AI sales training