1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. How to Sell to a Financial Director
Sales Training· South Africa

How to Sell to a Financial Director

How to sell to a financial director: lead with Price, Safety and Speed, show the return over a year and pass the safety gate, with word-for-word call lines.

··19 min read
Salesperson presenting a laminated annual ROI document with rand figures and risk comparison columns to a skeptical financial director in a bright corporate reception area.

AI-generated

TL;DR: Quick Answer

How to sell to a financial director: lead with Price, Safety and Speed, and put every claim in rand over a year. Show the return, not only the amount, then prove your offer is at least as safe as what they use now. The six value principles in the sales training guide explain why.

  • A financial director sees the cost, carries the risk and wants things done on time, so compare your price with their current spend over twelve months.
  • 'Too expensive' usually means 'I cannot see the return yet'. In our made-up example, R42,000 a year is set against R124,800 of clerk time.
  • Pass the safety gate before you talk about anything else, then practise the opening out loud on the sales call simulator.

Selling to a financial director is different from selling to an owner or an office manager, because the financial director is paid to ask what a purchase costs and what it risks. This article teaches step 1 of Mike Steenkamp's method, talk to the right person, and then the steps that carry you through the call once you have them on the line. Their role tells you what to lead with, and for finance that is Price, Safety and Speed.

The job title changes from business to business. You may meet a financial director, a CFO, a financial manager or a finance manager. The thinking is the same, so this guide on how to sell to a financial director also covers selling to a CFO and selling to finance in general, with word-for-word lines you can use on your next call. If you want the whole method first, start with the six value principles of selling.

Key Takeaways

  • Finance buyers start with Price, Safety and Speed. In the made-up fleet example below, the year-one saving is R9,800 and the year-two saving is R16,800, once switching costs are counted.
  • Ask the financial director for their own numbers, do the sum with them, and pass the safety gate before you argue about price.
  • ShiftMate Sim Studio lets a sales team practise the 'too expensive' answer out loud on AI buyers, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

How to sell to a financial director: lead with Price, Safety and Speed

To sell to a financial director, lead with Price, Safety and Speed, because they see the cost, they carry the risk and they want things done on time. Each of the three has a job in your call.

  • Price: show it costs less over a year than what they use now. Never sell on price alone, because cheaper does not mean better.
  • Safety: show it is at least as safe as what they use now. In money, health and data, nothing counts until you do.
  • Speed: show the time it saves. 'Faster' on its own just gets 'Faster than what?'

Notice what is missing. Quality, Ease and Volume can matter later in the conversation, but they are not where a finance buyer starts. This is the prove value with the six value principles step: show Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume or Price, compared with what they use now and backed with a number or an example. Here is how the lead changes with the buyer's role.

What to lead with, by the buyer's role

Buyer's roleLead with
Admin and office staffEase, Speed
FinancePrice, Safety, Speed
OwnerPrice, Volume
Marketing and salesVolume, Quality
OperationsSpeed, Ease, Quality
ProcurementPrice, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Why only two or three reasons? Research on business buying supports the choice. Eric Almquist, Jamie Cleghorn and Lori Sherer of Bain & Company, writing in the Harvard Business Review, found that business buyers weigh up to 40 'elements of value'. These run from table stakes such as meeting specifications, an acceptable price and regulatory compliance, through functional and ease-of-doing-business value, to personal concerns such as reduced anxiety and reputational assurance. You can read it in The B2B Elements of Value.

That last group matters for finance. A financial director signs off, and answers for the decision later. Safety is partly a personal concern, and you answer it with proof, not reassurance.

A second piece of research tells you how many reasons to bring. James Anderson, James Narus and Wouter van Rossum found that value propositions listing every benefit, or every difference from a competitor, are weaker than a 'resonating focus': the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against their next best alternative and backed with evidence. See Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets. For finance, the next best alternative is simply what they use now.

Relevance is also a matter of respect for the buyer's time. Most of the research on buyers comes from the United States and Europe, so treat it as a pointer, not a South African figure. Still, it points the same way as common sense.

What does a financial director mean by 'too expensive'?

When a financial director says 'too expensive', they usually mean 'I cannot see the return yet', not 'I do not have the money'. The amount is only half of the sentence. The other half is what the amount buys.

A tool that costs R42,000 a year and saves R62,400 of staff time is cheap. A tool that costs R4,000 a year and saves nothing is expensive. A financial director thinks this way all day, so a quote with no return beside it looks incomplete to them.

That is the heart of how to sell to a financial director who pushes back on cost. Do not argue with the amount and do not drop your price at once. Use step 7 of the method, agree and redirect: agree that the amount is real, then redirect to what you do better, in their numbers. Our objection handling guide has eight answers in the same pattern.

Worked example one (made up): the 'too expensive' call

Priya Naidoo sells invoicing and collections software for an invented company, Kudubill Software. She is speaking to Johan Pretorius, financial director of Brandvlei Distribution, an invented company. Every name and number here is made up to show the technique.

Johan: 'R3,500 a month. That is too expensive for what it does.'

Priya: 'I agree, R3,500 a month is real money, so let's compare it with what you spend today. That is R42,000 a year. How many hours a week do your two clerks spend chasing and capturing invoices?'

Johan: 'About ten each.'

Priya: 'So twenty hours a week, which is 1,040 hours a year. What does an hour of a clerk cost you, with everything included?'

Johan: 'Around R120.'

Priya: 'Then that time costs you R124,800 a year. If we took half of it away, that is R62,400 against R42,000, so about R20,400 a year in your favour. Does half sound right to you, or should we test a lower number?'

Look at what Priya did. She agreed first. She asked for Johan's numbers instead of using her own. She did the sum out loud, and she offered to test a lower figure. Johan can now argue with the percentage, but not with the method.

This call has not passed the safety gate yet. A good financial director will ask about that next, and so should you, before they have to.

How do you put everything in numbers over a year?

You put everything in numbers over a year by turning each claim into rand per twelve months and setting it beside what the buyer spends today. A monthly fee hides the real cost, and a 'saves time' claim with no number is easy to wave away.

Use this five-line routine every time you practise how to sell to a financial director:

  1. Write down their current yearly cost for the thing you would replace.
  2. Write down your yearly cost, including any one-off setup.
  3. Turn hours, errors or delays you remove into rand, using their numbers, not yours.
  4. Say honestly what switching costs them in time, training and overlap.
  5. Show the net figure for year one and for year two.

Year one and year two are different on purpose. Setup costs fall into year one, so the first-year saving is smaller. A finance buyer will find that out anyway, so say it first.

Wrong way and right way

Wrong way Right way Why it works
'It is only R380 per truck per month.' 'For 20 trucks, that is R91,200 a year, against R108,000 today.' A finance buyer thinks in yearly totals, not per-unit fees.
'It will save you a lot of time.' 'You told me ten hours a week. At R120 an hour, what is that a year?' The number is theirs, so it is harder to dismiss.
'Our competitors cost more.' 'Against what you use now, this costs less over twelve months. Here is the line by line.' The comparison is with their next best alternative, which is what they use today.
'There are no hidden costs.' 'Setup is R7,000 once, so year one saves less than year two. Here are both.' Honesty about switching builds trust, and finance respects it.

Worked example two (made up): a distribution business in Johannesburg

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Google (2,156+ Google reviews)

Grant Mostert sells vehicle tracking for an invented company, Veldspruit Fleet Tracking. His buyer, Karin Botha, is the financial manager of an invented company, Kameeldoring Packaging. It runs 20 delivery trucks from a depot near Johannesburg. All figures below are made up.

  • Current provider: R450 per truck per month, so R9,000 a month and R108,000 a year.
  • Veldspruit: R380 per truck per month, so R7,600 a month and R91,200 a year.
  • Yearly difference: R108,000 minus R91,200 is R16,800.
  • One-off setup: R350 per truck, so R7,000 for 20 trucks.
  • Year one: R16,800 minus R7,000 is R9,800 saved. Year two: R16,800 saved.

Grant says: 'In the first year it saves about R9,800 after setup, and from the second year about R16,800. But the number I most want to check with you is how long it takes your team to build the month-end vehicle cost report today.'

That last sentence is Speed. Price alone is a weak place to stand, because a competitor can match it. Price together with Speed and Safety is a case a finance buyer can take to their own managing director.

A year-in-rand sheet you can copy

Print this and fill it in with the buyer on the call, or send it afterwards as your agreed next step. The last column shows what good looks like.

Line What goes in What good looks like
What they use now Their yearly cost in rand The buyer gave you the number and agreed it.
Your offer Your yearly cost, plus one-off setup Nothing is left out, and nothing is rounded in your favour.
Time or errors removed Hours or mistakes, times their cost Built from their figures, with a lower case beside it.
Cost of switching Training, overlap, internal time You raised it before they did.
Net, year one and year two Two separate rand figures The buyer can repeat both figures to their own managing director.

How to sell to a financial director: how do you pass the safety gate?

You pass the safety gate by showing, before you argue about anything else, that your offer is at least as safe as what the buyer uses now. In financial services, insurance, healthcare and software, nothing else counts until the buyer is sure of that. This is step 5 of the method, show it's safe.

The gate is strongest in those four industries, but a financial director in any industry feels it, because money and data are always theirs to protect. The method scores Safety at 4 out of 10 in insurance and in financial services, and 2 in software with data security as the gate. Here is what that looks like for software.

Software: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)

Safety 2
Quality 1
Ease 3
Speed 2
Volume 1
Price 1

Safety gate (data security): nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is safe.

Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Safety for a finance buyer is concrete. They want to know what happens to their money or their data, who can see it, and what happens on the day something goes wrong. They also want to know what their auditor would ask to see.

A safety proof checklist you can copy

Have an answer ready for each of these before you call. If you do not have one, say so and offer to find out.

  • Money or data: where it sits, who can see it, and who can change it.
  • If it fails: what the buyer loses, how long it takes to get help, and who they phone.
  • Compared with today: a plain statement of where you are at least as safe as their current setup, and where you are different.
  • Evidence: a real reference they can phone, or a trial period, only if you genuinely offer one.
  • Their auditor: the documents or reports you can hand over on request.

Do not explain a law or a regulator's rule from memory, and do not guess. Where compliance comes into the conversation, check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your own business, and bring that person to the next call if the financial director asks.

A line you can use: 'Before we talk about price, may I show you how this compares with what you use now on safety? If it is not at least as safe, nothing else I say matters.' Buyers rarely hear a seller say that, and finance respects it.

If you sell into an insurance broker in Cape Town or a software house in Pretoria, expect the safety questions to come first. If they do not, raise them yourself.

How to sell to a financial director: what to say in the first minute

In the first minute, say who you are, your company, what the call is about, how you got their details, what you want and, above all, why it matters to them. This is step 2 of the method, earn the right to talk, and it comes after you have checked you have the right person.

Step 1 is the check. Confirm the company is a fit and that you are speaking to the person who decides. If you reach a finance manager rather than the financial director, ask who signs off a purchase like yours. Here is how to sell to finance managers who report to the director: ask who signs off, and help them build the case. Selling to finance managers is useful, because they often prepare the numbers, but you need to know who decides. Our article on cold calling tips that work in South Africa covers getting past the front desk.

Step 3 is a reminder: the default answer is no. The buyer is thinking 'convince me', and until you show it is good for them, the answer stays no. The checklist below shows what each part of the opening is worth.

The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)

Who you are 1
Your company 1
What your company does (must be said) 0
What the call is about 2
How you got their details 1
What you want from this call 2
Why it matters to them 3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Seven out of ten is a good opening. A tough buyer needs eight or nine, and a financial director is usually a tough buyer. Notice that 'what your company does' earns nothing on its own: it must be said, but the points come from why it matters to them.

A scored opening you can copy (made up)

Grant Mostert calls Karin Botha, using the same invented companies as before. Each line is scored against the checklist.

What Grant says Part of the checklist Points
'Good morning Karin, my name is Grant Mostert.' Who you are 1
'I am with Veldspruit Fleet Tracking.' Your company 1
'We supply vehicle tracking to distribution businesses.' What your company does 0
'I am calling about what your fleet tracking costs you over a year, and how safe it is.' What the call is about 2
'I found your name on your company's website, under finance.' How you got their details 1
'I would like to send you a one-page yearly comparison and set a time to talk it through.' What you want from this call 2
'Finance usually carries both the cost and the risk if a tracker fails, so I want you to see both side by side.' Why it matters to them 3

That adds up to 10. In real life you will not get it word-perfect, which is why it needs practice out loud. Our telesales script examples and sales role play examples give you more openings to work from.

How do you give a financial director a real reason to act now?

You give a financial director a real reason to act now by showing what waiting costs them, a real date, or a change in their business, and never by inventing urgency. This is step 6 of the method, give a real reason to act now.

Finance buyers spot fake urgency quickly. 'The price goes up on Friday' only works if it is true, and if it is not, you have damaged the one thing you need most, which is trust.

Here are three honest reasons, using the made-up fleet example:

  • What waiting costs: 'On the numbers we built, every month you stay on the current contract costs about R1,400.' That is R16,800 divided by 12.
  • A real date: 'You told me your current contract renews on 31 March. May we agree a decision date before the notice period?'
  • A change in their business: 'You said you are opening a second depot. Would it be easier to set up both depots at the same time?'

If there is no honest reason, do not make one up. Say so and agree on a next step instead. That is how to sell to a financial director without pressure.

Agree and redirect, then earn the next step

Objections will come. A common one from finance is 'We already have a provider.' Use step 7, agree and redirect, and be honest about what switching involves.

Karin: 'We already have a provider, and switching is a hassle.'

Grant: 'I agree, switching is real work, and I will not pretend otherwise. It is R7,000 once and about a day per truck. What I would like to show you is where the year-two numbers end up, and how it compares with your current setup on safety. Can I send that today?'

Then use step 8, earn the next step. You do not close on the first call. Agree to send the information and a set time to talk again, for example: 'I will send the one-page sheet this afternoon. Would Thursday at 10:00 work to go through it together?'

What does this not solve?

What this does not solve is a weak offer, a buyer who does not decide, or a team that has never practised, so be honest with yourself about each one.

  • It does not fix a less safe product. If your offer is not at least as safe as what they use now, no script gets you through the gate.
  • It does not make you the only voice. A financial director is rarely the only person involved in a purchase.
  • It does not replace their numbers. If you invent figures, finance will find the gap and you will lose the call.
  • It does not tell you the compliance rules. Check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business.
  • It will not always win on price. Sometimes a cheaper option wins. Cheaper does not mean better, but a financial director may choose it anyway, and you should know when to walk away.

On the point about many voices, Forrester's 2024 research on business buying, which is US-based, reports the following.

That is one reason the next step in the method matters. Give the financial director something they can forward: the year-in-rand sheet is built for that.

Finally, none of this works if you have only read it. Selling is a spoken skill. Say the opening and the 'too expensive' answer out loud, with someone who will answer back, until you can say them without reading. Score each attempt on the sales call scorecard template.

How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help

ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. For this topic, practise the opening and the 'too expensive' answer on the sales call simulator before you try them on a real financial director. See also AI sales training for teams. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed.

Frequently asked questions

How do you sell to a financial director?

Lead with Price, Safety and Speed, because a financial director sees the cost, carries the risk and wants things done on time. Put every claim in rand over a year, use their own numbers, and show your offer is at least as safe as what they use now before you discuss anything else.

What do financial directors care about most when buying?

They care about what something costs over a year, whether it is at least as safe as what they use now, and whether it saves time. In Mike Steenkamp's method, finance is led with Price, Safety and Speed, because they see the cost, carry the risk and want work done on time.

What do you say when a CFO says it is too expensive?

Agree that the amount is real, then redirect to the return. For example: 'I agree, R42,000 a year is real money, so let's compare it with what you spend today.' Then ask for their numbers, do the sum with them, and offer to test a lower figure. Never drop your price first.

How is selling to a CFO different from selling to an owner?

An owner is led with Price and Volume, because the money comes out of their pocket and they want the business to grow. A CFO is led with Price, Safety and Speed, because they carry the risk and the deadlines. The CFO will also want proof of safety before any other benefit counts.

How do you sell to finance managers who cannot sign off?

Ask who decides, and give the finance manager something they can take to that person: a one-page yearly comparison in rand, built from their own numbers. Finance managers often prepare the case, so help them make it clearly, and agree a set time to talk again.

Should you offer a discount to win a financial director?

No, not as your first move. Never sell on price alone, because cheaper does not mean better, and a discount without a return invites more pressure. Show the cost over a year against what they use now, and be honest about the cost of switching.

How can I practise how to sell to a financial director?

Practise out loud, with feedback, until the opening and the 'too expensive' answer come easily. A team can practise on AI buyers in the ShiftMate Sim Studio sales call simulator, where each practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. You can also role play with a colleague and score it on a scorecard.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

See AI sales training

Sources & References

  • https://www.bain.com/insights/the-b2b-elements-of-value-hbr/ - business buyers weigh up to 40 elements of value, including table stakes and personal concerns
  • https://hbr.org/2006/03/customer-value-propositions-in-business-markets - value propositions work best with a resonating focus on one or two differences against the next best alternative
  • https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2025-06-25-gartner-sales-survey-finds-61-percent-of-b2b-buyers-prefer-a-rep-free-buying-experience - 73% of B2B buyers avoid suppliers who send irrelevant outreach
  • https://www.forrester.com/press-newsroom/forrester-the-state-of-business-buying-2024/ - 13 people on average are involved in a B2B buying decision

All legal information verified as of 16 November 2026. Consult with a labour lawyer for specific cases.

Keep reading