1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. 'We're Happy With Our Current Supplier': What to Say
Sales Training· South Africa

'We're Happy With Our Current Supplier': What to Say

We're happy with our current supplier is a polite no, not a final one. Get word-for-word agree and redirect lines, a gap question and a side-by-side comparison.

··19 min read
Salesperson standing at an outdoor bistro table beside a commercial building, gesturing toward a printed supplier comparison sheet during a face-to-face business conversation.

AI-generated

TL;DR: Quick Answer

When a buyer says we're happy with our current supplier, do not argue and do not run the supplier down. Agree that a working supplier is worth keeping, ask one question that finds what is still not perfect, then show a fair side-by-side comparison on the one or two things that matter most to that buyer.

  • This is step 7 of Mike Steenkamp's method, agree and redirect, taught in the sales training guide.
  • Be honest about switching: a saving of R350 a month is R4,200 over a year, but a once-off setup fee of R1,500 leaves R2,700, so show the whole sum.
  • Next step: practise the three lines in this article out loud on the sales call simulator before your next real call.

"We're happy with our current supplier" is the most polite no a buyer can give you. It sounds final, but it usually only tells you that nothing has gone wrong badly enough to make them look at someone new. Your job on the call is not to prove them wrong. It is to find out whether "happy" means "perfect" or "good enough", and to show one difference that is worth a second conversation.

The answer has three moves: agree, ask, compare. It is step 7 of the method, agree and redirect, and it only works if the earlier steps did their job. This article gives you word-for-word lines for each move, two made-up example calls, a table you can copy, and an honest list of what this approach cannot fix.

Key Takeaways

  • Never run down the supplier the buyer chose. A R350 a month saving is R4,200 a year, but if switching costs R1,500 once, say so and show the net R2,700.
  • Agree first, then ask one question that finds the gap, then compare on one or two of the six value principles, not all six.
  • ShiftMate Sim Studio lets a team practise this objection out loud on AI buyers and get a report with one thing to fix first.

What do you say when a buyer says we're happy with our current supplier?

Say that you are glad it is working, then ask a question that shows whether it works perfectly or only well enough. You are not asking them to leave anyone. You are asking permission to compare.

Here is the shape of the answer, in your own voice:

  1. Agree. "That's good to hear. A supplier who looks after you is worth keeping."
  2. Ask. "What do they do best for you at the moment?" Then: "And if you could change one thing, what would it be?"
  3. Compare. "Would it help if I sent you a one-page comparison on that one thing, so you can see it next to what you have now?"

Notice what is missing. There is no "but", no "have you thought about" and no list of everything you offer. The buyer has told you the default answer is no, which is exactly what step 3 of the method says: remember the default answer is no. The buyer is thinking "convince me". Pushing harder only makes the no firmer.

This is the current supplier objection response in its simplest form. If you have a minute only, learn those three lines. The rest of this article explains why they work and how to adjust them to the buyer in front of you.

Why is "we're happy with our current supplier" so hard to answer?

It is hard because it sounds like a fact, not an objection, and because the buyer, or a colleague, chose that supplier. If you criticise the supplier, you criticise their judgement, and they will defend it.

The happy with current supplier objection also hides several different things. It can mean any of these:

  • "I'm busy." Looking at a new supplier is work, and the current one asks nothing of them today.
  • "I don't know you yet." Your opening did not earn the right to talk, so they fall back on the safe answer.
  • "Switching is risky." They remember a change that went badly, or they cannot see how it would go well.
  • "I'm genuinely satisfied." This is real, and your job is then to find out how satisfied.

The already have a supplier objection often shows up in the first thirty seconds. When it does, look at your opening before you look at the buyer. The opening checklist below is worth ten points, and the biggest single item is why the call matters to them.

Here is how those ten points are split, so you can check your own opening against it.

The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)

Who you are 1
Your company 1
What your company does (must be said) 0
What the call is about 2
How you got their details 1
What you want from this call 2
Why it matters to them 3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Seven of ten is a good opening, and a tough buyer needs eight or nine. "What your company does" scores nothing on its own, because every cold caller says it. Most "we're happy" answers come from openings that spent their time there and skipped "why it matters to you".

Switching also involves more people than the person on your call. Forrester's 2024 research on business buying, which is not a South African figure, found that many people sit inside a typical purchase decision:

That is one reason a quick "yes, switch" is rare, and why "happy" is a safe place to stand. If the buyer needs to carry the idea to colleagues, give them something they can carry: a short comparison, not a pitch.

Relevance matters too. Gartner's 2025 survey, again of buyers in other markets, reports how many avoid suppliers whose outreach is not relevant to them:

So the answer to "we're happy" cannot be a general speech about your company. It has to be about the one thing that is relevant to this buyer.

Finally, remember what you are up against. The buyer's current supplier is what researchers call the "next best alternative". Anderson, Narus and van Rossum, writing in Harvard Business Review in 2006, found that value propositions listing every benefit are weaker than a "resonating focus": the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against their next best alternative and backed with evidence. That is exactly what the rest of this article teaches you to do.

How do you agree and redirect without running down their supplier?

You agree with the part that is true, which is that a working supplier has value, then you redirect to one thing you do better, and you are honest about what switching involves. You never say anything negative about the supplier by name.

There are three reasons not to criticise them. First, you probably do not know their service as well as the buyer does. Second, the buyer picked them. Third, it makes you sound like every other caller. This is step 7 of the method, agree and redirect, and the order matters: agree first, redirect second.

The table below puts the wrong way next to the right way, with the reason.

What the buyer says The wrong answer The right answer Why it works
"We're happy with our current supplier." "Everyone says that, until something goes wrong." "That's good to hear. What do they do best for you?" It agrees, and it gets the buyer talking about what they value.
"We've used them for years." "Maybe it's time for a change." "Years of good service is worth a lot. Is there one thing you'd still like to be easier?" It respects their choice and looks for a small gap.
"We don't need anyone else." "We're cheaper than them." "I'm not asking you to replace them. Could a second quote help you keep them sharp?" It lowers the risk and keeps the conversation open.
"Send me something." "Sure, what's your email?" and nothing more. "Happy to. So it's useful, which one thing should it cover? And can we talk for ten minutes on Thursday?" It earns a set time, which is step 8 of the method.

Look at the last row. "Send me something" is often another way of saying no. If you accept it without a set time to talk again, the call is over. Step 8, earn the next step, reminds you that you do not close on the first call. You agree to send information and a set time to talk again.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Google (2,156+ Google reviews)

Be honest about what switching involves

The redirect only works if it is honest. A buyer who is happy has already thought about what could go wrong. If you say "switching is easy" and it is not, you lose them. Say what is true:

  • "There's a setup step on our side. It takes about a week, and I'd handle most of it."
  • "You'd keep your current supplier until the first order from us has arrived and you're happy."
  • "There is a once-off setup fee of R1,500. I'll show you where it pays back, and where it doesn't."

Plain honesty here is not a weakness. For many buyers it is the first sign that you are different from the callers who promise everything.

What question finds the gap behind a happy customer?

The best question is a specific one about a part of the service, not a general "is there anything wrong?". A buyer who is happy will say "no" to a general question. A specific question gives them something to think about.

The method gives you six reasons a business buys, the six value principles: Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume and Price. Each one gives you a question to find a gap. Copy these and keep them next to the phone:

  • Safety: "How confident are you that the data or money is protected if their system goes down?"
  • Quality: "When did you last compare the product or the result against another supplier's sample?"
  • Ease: "Walk me through what happens from the moment you need something to the moment it arrives. Where do you spend the most time?"
  • Speed: "When you need it urgently, how long does it actually take?"
  • Volume: "If your business grew by a third next year, would they be able to keep up?"
  • Price: "When did you last check what you pay against the market?"

You do not ask all six. Ask one or two, chosen by who you are talking to. Their role tells you what to lead with, which is step 1 of the method: talk to the right person. The chart below shows which reasons to buy to lead with, by role.

What to lead with, by the buyer's role

Buyer's roleLead with
Admin and office staffEase, Speed
FinancePrice, Safety, Speed
OwnerPrice, Volume
Marketing and salesVolume, Quality
OperationsSpeed, Ease, Quality
ProcurementPrice, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Use it to pick your question. With admin and office staff, ask about Ease and Speed, and never lead with Price: it is not their money. With an owner, ask about Price and Volume. With finance, ask about Price, Safety and Speed. With procurement, ask about Price and Quality. With operations, ask about Speed, Ease and Quality. With marketing and sales, ask about Volume and Quality.

How to listen to the answer

The question only works if you then stop talking. Write down the buyer's exact words, and use them in your comparison. A buyer who hears their own words repeated feels understood. A meta-analysis of 664 effect sizes in the Journal of Business and Psychology (2023), from general workplace research and not a sales study, found a link between being seen as a good listener and work outcomes:

In practice, that means a short pause after the buyer answers and a line like "So the slow part is when you reorder in a hurry. Is that right?" Then you have the gap in their words, not yours.

How do you compare side by side and keep the call going?

You offer a short comparison on the one or two things the buyer just told you matter, laid out against how they do it today, and you agree a time to go through it together. Offering to compare is a smaller ask than offering to switch.

Step 4 of the method is prove value with the six value principles: show Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume or Price, compared with what they use now and backed with a number or an example. The comparison is how you do that without attacking the supplier. You use the buyer's own description of what they have now.

Here is a table you can copy. Fill the left column from what the buyer told you, and the right column from your own offer. The last column tells you what good looks like.

What matters (their words) How they do it today How you would do it What good looks like
One principle, such as Ease or Speed Described by the buyer, step by step Same steps, with the difference shown A number or an example the buyer can check
Cost over a year Monthly cost times twelve Your monthly cost times twelve, plus any setup fee The net figure, with the setup fee included
What switching involves Nothing, they are already set up The real steps, who does them and how long they take No surprises later
Safety, if it applies Their current protection Yours, in the same terms At least as safe as what they have now

Keep it to one page. Anderson and colleagues' point about a "resonating focus" applies: the comparison with one or two differences that matter beats the one with twelve. If you do compare on price, never sell on price alone. Cheaper does not mean better, and a buyer who is happy will not move for a small saving.

Close the call with a set time

Do not end with "I'll send it through and hear from you". End with a date. Try this:

  • "I'll send the one-page comparison by 4 pm today. Can we take ten minutes on Thursday at 9 to go through it together?"
  • "If Thursday doesn't work, would Friday morning be better?"

A time in both diaries is the difference between a polite no and a second call. If you want a longer set of lines for other objections, the objection handling guide has eight answers on the same agree and redirect pattern.

Two made-up calls: what it sounds like

Both examples below are made up. The people and companies do not exist.

Example 1 (made up): stationery for an office manager

Grant sells stationery and printer supplies for an invented company, Mopani Office Supplies. He phones Karin Botha, the office manager at Vaalridge Fleet Hire, also invented. An office manager is admin staff, so Grant leads with Ease and Speed and stays away from Price.

  • Grant: "Karin, it's Grant from Mopani Office Supplies. We supply stationery and printer toner to offices in the Free State. I'm calling because I got your name from your website, and I'd like to ask two quick questions about how you reorder. It might save you some admin each month."
  • Karin: "Thanks, Grant, but we're happy with our current supplier."
  • Grant: "That's good to hear, Karin. A supplier who looks after you is worth keeping. What do they do best for you?"
  • Karin: "They're reliable. Things arrive."
  • Grant: "Good. And if you could change one thing, what would it be?"
  • Karin: "Honestly, the ordering. I email a list, and sometimes it comes back a day later with the wrong toner."
  • Grant: "So the slow part is the email list. Would a one-page comparison help, showing how a saved reorder list works next to how you order now? I'd send it today, and we could talk for ten minutes on Thursday."
  • Karin: "Fine. Send it, and Thursday at ten works."

Grant never said a word against the other supplier. He found one gap, in Karin's words, and earned a set time. He did not win the order on the first call, and he was not trying to.

Different industries weigh the six principles differently. For a business telecoms seller, for example, the weights below show what counts most.

Business telecoms: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)

Safety 2
Quality 2
Ease 3
Speed 1
Volume 0
Price 2
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Example 2 (made up): business phone lines for an owner

Priya sells business phone lines for an invented company, Tafelvlei Telecoms. She phones Johan Pretorius, who owns Pretorius Plumbing Supplies, also invented. An owner cares about Price and Volume, so Priya leads with those, and shows the whole sum.

  • Johan: "We're happy with our current supplier, Priya."
  • Priya: "Good, Johan. Phones are one thing you want to forget about. When did you last check what you pay a month against the market?"
  • Johan: "It's R2,450. I haven't looked in a few years."
  • Priya: "Then let me be straight. Our quote for the same lines is R2,100 a month. That is R350 less, which is R4,200 over a year. There is a once-off setup fee of R1,500, so the first year saving is R2,700, and the full R4,200 from the second year. I'd keep your current lines running until the new ones work."
  • Johan: "And if the service is worse?"
  • Priya: "That's the right question. Cheaper doesn't mean better, so I'd like to show you how we handle faults, next to what you have now. Can I send that with the numbers, and call you Wednesday at 8:30?"

Priya used the number the buyer gave her, did the sum for a year, and included the fee that works against her. She also raised the risk before Johan could. That is what honest looks like. If you sell financial services or insurance, check what you may say about a competitor's product with the person responsible for compliance in your business before you use a comparison like this.

What this does not solve

This approach does not make every buyer switch, and it is not meant to. Be honest with yourself about where it stops.

  • A buyer who is genuinely delighted. If the supplier is excellent and nothing could be better, the right result is a polite "keep in touch". Note a date to call back and move on.
  • A buyer who is locked in. A contract that runs for another year means no switch now. You may still agree a call close to the renewal date.
  • The wrong person. If you are not speaking to the person who decides, no objection answer will help. Go back to step 1, talk to the right person.
  • A weak offer. If you cannot show a real, checkable difference, there is no gap to redirect to. Fix the offer, not the script.
  • Invented urgency. Step 6 says to give a real reason to act now: what waiting costs them, a real date, or a change in their business. Never make one up.

Also, a script is not a result. Reading these lines will not make you good at them. That takes practice.

What to practise this week

Practise out loud, not in your head. Pick one buyer role, one principle and the three-move answer, and say it ten times, until you stop sounding as if you are reading. Then practise the hard version, where the buyer pushes back twice.

The sales call simulator lets you practise this objection against an AI buyer, and the sales role play examples give you eight scenarios with scripts if you would rather practise with a colleague. A meta-analysis of 145 studies in higher education, so not a sales study, found that learning through simulation has a large effect on complex skills:

Coaching matters as well. A Salesforce survey of sales professionals,, not a South African one, reports how many get regular one-to-one coaching:

If you manage a team, score the calls so feedback is specific. The sales call scorecard template gives you a way to do it. For the opening lines that come before this objection, see the telesales script examples, and for the overall method, the AI sales training for teams page.

How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help

ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer. Every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed.

Frequently asked questions

How do you respond when a buyer says we're happy with our current supplier?

Agree first, then ask, then compare. Say you are glad it works, ask what the supplier does best and what the buyer would change if they could, and offer a short side-by-side comparison on that one thing. Never criticise the supplier, and agree a set time to talk again.

Should I ask who the buyer's current supplier is?

You can, but ask gently and only after you have agreed with them. A line such as "Who looks after you at the moment?" is fine if the buyer is relaxed. If they hesitate, move to "what do they do best for you?" instead. You do not need the name to find the gap.

How do I answer "we've used them for years" without sounding pushy?

Respect the history. Say that years of good service is worth a lot, then ask whether there is one thing the buyer would still like to be easier or quicker. You are not asking them to leave, only to look at one comparison so they know where they stand.

What if the buyer's supplier really is good?

Then accept it and keep the door open. Ask what they would need to see before they would look at anyone else, note it, and agree a date to call back, such as close to their renewal. A good supplier does not stop you being the second quote they trust.

Does a lower price beat the already have a supplier objection?

Rarely on its own. Cheaper does not mean better, and a happy buyer will not move for a small saving, especially if switching costs time or a setup fee. Show the cost over a year, include any once-off fee, and lead with Price only when the buyer is an owner, finance or procurement.

How many times should I try before I accept the answer is no?

Try once with the three-move answer, and once more if the buyer gives you a gap to work with. If they stay firm after you have agreed, asked and offered a comparison, thank them, ask whether you may call again in three months, and note the date. Pushing past a clear no costs you the next call.

How do I practise the current supplier objection response before a real call?

Say it out loud, to a colleague or to an AI buyer, and ask for feedback on one thing at a time. Practise the agree line, the gap question and the set time until they sound natural. Then practise a buyer who pushes back twice, since that is what real calls do.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

See AI sales training

Sources & References

  • https://hbr.org/2006/03/customer-value-propositions-in-business-markets: resonating focus against the next best alternative
  • https://www.forrester.com/press-newsroom/forrester-the-state-of-business-buying-2024/: 13 people in a buying decision
  • https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2025-06-25-gartner-sales-survey-finds-61-percent-of-b2b-buyers-prefer-a-rep-free-buying-experience: irrelevant outreach
  • https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10869-023-09897-5: listening meta-analysis
  • https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.3102/0034654320933544: simulation-based learning
  • https://www.salesforce.com/news/stories/sales-research-2023/: coaching frequency

All legal information verified as of 16 November 2026. Consult with a labour lawyer for specific cases.

Keep reading