1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. How to Sell Against a Competitor Without Naming Them
Sales Training· South Africa

How to Sell Against a Competitor Without Naming Them

Learn how to sell against a competitor without naming them: the questions to ask, how to agree and redirect, and a 20-minute weekly drill from three lost deals.

··18 min read
Salesperson presenting a printed criteria scorecard at a corporate reception counter while a prospect listens attentively in a glass-walled office lobby.

AI-generated

TL;DR: Quick Answer

To sell against a competitor without naming them, ask why the buyer chose their current supplier and how it is going, then ask questions that set the standard you win on: support, switching cost and the true cost over a year. Agree with what works, redirect to what you do better, and practise it weekly.

  • It rests on the six value principles in the sales training guide: Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume and Price.
  • How to sell against a competitor is about the standard you set: a R1,500 a month saving is R18,000 a year, and weak support or a messy switch can eat it (made-up figures).
  • Next: take three lost deals and run a 20-minute drill on them this week.

Here is how to sell against a competitor without ever saying their name: you get the buyer to describe, in their own words, why they chose the current supplier and where it falls short, and you set the standard you win on. Buyers already know who they use. They do not need you to tell them, and they do not trust a seller who tries.

This article teaches step seven of Mike Steenkamp's method, agree and redirect, and shows how it turns selling against competitors into a calm conversation instead of an argument. It ends with a 20-minute weekly drill built from three lost deals that you can run with your team on Friday.

Key Takeaways

  • Compare over a year, not a month: in the made-up telecoms example below, R3,600 extra on the invoice saves R13,500 of lost time.
  • Ask three standard-setting questions about support, switching cost and true cost over a year, and never say the rival's name.
  • ShiftMate Sim Studio lets your team practise these calls out loud on AI buyers, and every call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

How to sell against a competitor without naming them

The short answer is that you replace statements about them with questions about the buyer. You ask why they chose the supplier they have. You ask how it is going. Then you ask a few questions that make the buyer think about support, switching cost and what the service costs over a full year. Only after that do you agree with what is good about their choice and redirect to what you do better.

Every seller does some competitive selling, whether they plan it or not. Someone always has the account before you. The difference between a good seller and a poor one is what happens when the buyer says "we already have someone". The poor seller reaches for the rival's weak points. The good seller gets curious.

In the method, this is step 7: agree with the objection, then redirect to what you do better, and be honest about what switching involves. It works because it leans on step 3, where you remember that the default answer is no. The buyer is thinking "convince me". Running down a supplier they chose does not convince them. It tells them you are the kind of person who runs people down.

Here are the eight steps in call order, so you can see where this one sits.

The sales method: eight steps, in call order

  1. Talk to the right person
  2. Earn the right to talk
  3. Remember the default answer is no
  4. Prove value with the six value principles
  5. Show it's safe
  6. Give a real reason to act now
  7. Agree and redirect
  8. Earn the next step
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

The four moves in this article are:

  1. Ask why they chose their current supplier. Listen for the reason, because it tells you which value principle they care about.
  2. Ask how it is going. Let them find the gaps themselves.
  3. Ask the standard-setting questions. Support, switching cost, true cost over a year.
  4. Agree, then redirect. Say what is genuinely good, then show what you do better, with the honest cost of switching.

Why does naming the rival cost you the sale?

Naming the rival costs you the sale because it makes the buyer defend their own decision. The moment you say "their service is poor", the person who chose them hears "you made a poor choice". They stop weighing your offer and start protecting themselves.

There is a second problem. Forrester reports that on average 13 people in an organisation are involved in a B2B buying decision, and that 86% of B2B purchases stall during the buying process. That is a United States research firm, not a South African figure, but the point travels. The person you are criticising may be the manager of the person you are talking to, or the person whose approval you need next week.

A third problem is credibility. You only know their side of the story from the outside. The buyer lives with the product every day. If you are wrong on one detail, everything else you say is doubted.

Look at the difference side by side.

The wrong way The right way Why it works
"Their support is terrible, everyone knows that." "When something goes wrong, how long does it usually take to get a person?" The buyer reaches the conclusion themselves.
"You're overpaying with them." "What does the service cost you over a full year, including the extras?" It shifts the talk to true cost, not the monthly price.
"Switching from them is easy." "Moving does take some work. Here is what it involves, step by step." Honesty about switching builds trust.
"Why did you pick them?" said with a sigh. "What made them the right choice at the time?" Tone matters: you are curious, not judging.

A note on regulated fields. If you sell in financial services, insurance or healthcare, check what applies to talking about other providers with the person responsible for compliance in your business. This article is about conversation skill, not about what you are allowed to say.

What do you ask instead of naming the competitor?

You ask five short questions in order: why they chose their current supplier, how it is going, and then three standard-setting questions about support, switching cost and the true cost over a year. Each question is neutral on its face. Together they let the buyer set the standard, and the standard is the one you win on.

The first two: why they chose them and how it is going

Start with the choice, not the fault. "What made you choose them?" gets you the buyer's real priorities. If they say "they were the cheapest", you know Price mattered then. If they say "they installed quickly", you know Speed mattered. This is a free lesson in which of the six value principles drives this buyer.

Then ask how it is going. "And how is it working for you today?" Leave a pause. People fill silence with the truth. Do not suggest the answer. Do not say "any problems?", because that sounds like you are fishing. Keep it open and let them talk.

The three that set your standard

Now you move from their story to the standard you win on. There are three questions, and you only ask the ones that fit your offer.

  • Support: "When something goes wrong, what happens? Who do you speak to, and how long does it take?"
  • Switching cost: "If you ever did change, what would worry you most about moving?"
  • True cost over a year: "What does it cost you across a full year, once you add everything that is not on the monthly invoice?"

Notice what these questions do. They never mention a rival. They define what "good" looks like, and they make the buyer measure their current supplier against it. If your offer is strong on those three, you have set a standard you win on without saying a single negative word.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Google (2,156+ Google reviews)

A script you can copy

Use this on your next call. Change the words to sound like you, but keep the order.

  1. "Thanks for being open about that. What made you choose them in the first place?"
  2. "That makes sense. And how is it going now?"
  3. "When something goes wrong, how long does it usually take to get a person who can fix it?"
  4. "If you ever did move, what would worry you most about the switch?"
  5. "Across a full year, what does it really cost you, including the things that are not on the invoice?"
  6. "Can I show you how we would handle those three things, and what moving would involve?"

Notice that question six asks permission. You are not pushing. You are offering to show the buyer something that matches what they just told you.

For more ready-made lines, see the telesales script examples, and for the opening of the call, see Cold Calling Tips: 9 That Work in South Africa.

Which value principle wins against the supplier they already have?

The principle that wins is usually one or two, not all six, and which ones depends on the buyer's role and industry. The six reasons a business buys are Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume and Price. In every competitive conversation you pick the one or two that matter most to this buyer and show them against what they use now.

Research backs the focus. Anderson, Narus and van Rossum, writing in Harvard Business Review in 2006, found that value propositions listing every benefit, or every difference from a competitor, are weaker than a resonating focus: the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against their next best alternative and backed with evidence. Your next best alternative is the supplier they have today. That is exactly who you are selling against, and you do it without naming them.

Bain's work on the B2B elements of value adds a human note. Business buyers weigh up to 40 elements of value, from meeting specifications to personal concerns such as reduced anxiety. Fear of a messy switch is one of those personal concerns. That is why honesty about what switching involves is part of the method, not an extra.

The method tells you what to lead with by the buyer's role. Study it before the call.

What to lead with, by the buyer's role

Buyer's roleLead with
Admin and office staffEase, Speed
FinancePrice, Safety, Speed
OwnerPrice, Volume
Marketing and salesVolume, Quality
OperationsSpeed, Ease, Quality
ProcurementPrice, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Then adjust for the industry. Here is how much each principle counts for a South African business telecoms seller, such as someone selling business fibre or a voice system.

Business telecoms: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)

Safety 2
Quality 2
Ease 3
Speed 1
Volume 0
Price 2
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

In business telecoms, Ease counts most, ahead of Safety, Quality and Price. So when you are up against an existing provider, your questions should lean toward effort and hassle: how many steps to get a fault fixed, who the buyer calls, how long they wait. If you sell insurance or financial services, Safety is a gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is at least as safe as what they have, so those questions come first.

Do you know how to sell against a competitor when the buyer says they are happy?

Yes: you agree that they are happy, you ask what is working, and then you redirect to one thing you do better, with an honest note on what switching involves. This is step 7 of the method, agree and redirect, and it is the heart of competitor objection handling.

"We are happy with our current supplier" is not a wall. It is a default answer. The buyer is thinking "convince me", and they are protecting a decision they already made. If you argue, you lose. If you agree, you earn the right to ask another question.

Example call one: business telecoms (made up)

This example is made up. Sarah sells for Quillon Telecoms, an invented company. Johan Pretorius owns a small accounting practice. Sarah never names Johan's current provider.

Sarah: "Johan, you said you are happy with your current provider. What made you choose them originally?"

Johan: "They were cheap and they installed quickly."

Sarah: "That makes sense. Price and speed both matter. How is it going now?"

Johan: "Fine, except when the line drops. Then we wait a day to get hold of anyone."

Sarah: "When it drops, what happens in your office while you wait?"

Johan: "Six of us can't work. I'd say that costs us about R4,500 in billable time, each time."

Sarah: "That is a lot. What does it cost you across a full year, including those days?"

Johan: "R1,850 a month is R22,200. It has dropped three times this year, so add R13,500."

Sarah: "So about R35,700 for the year. You are right that a cheaper monthly price matters. Our price is R2,150 a month, which is R25,800 a year, so R3,600 more on paper. What I do better is how fast a person answers when it drops. Would it help if I showed you how that works, and what moving would involve?"

Look at what Sarah did. She agreed ("price and speed both matter"). She let Johan do the sum. She admitted her price was higher. She redirected to the one thing she does better, and she offered to explain the switch. All the figures here are made up for the example, so work out your own over a year.

Example call two: office supplies (made up)

This example is also made up. Priya sells for Vlakte Office Supplies, an invented company, to Karin Botha, an office manager at a Durban distribution firm. Karin is an admin buyer, so Priya leads with Ease and Speed, not Price. It is not Karin's money.

Priya: "Karin, how does your standing order work at the moment?"

Karin: "I email a list every Monday. It works, mostly."

Priya: "Mostly. What happens on the weeks it doesn't?"

Karin: "Then I'm chasing, and people have no paper."

Priya: "That sounds stressful. You are right that the Monday email works when everything arrives. What I do better is the chasing. One person on your account, and a confirmation before the van leaves. I should be honest, though: moving your standing order takes about a week of checking, and you would run both for a short while. Does that seem worth a closer look?"

The honest line about the week of checking is not a weakness. It is what makes the rest believable. For more answers built the same way, see objection handling: agree and redirect, with eight answers, and for more scenes to rehearse, see these sales role play examples.

How to sell against a competitor: the 20-minute weekly drill from three lost deals

The drill is one 20-minute session a week, built from three deals you lost to a competitor. For each deal you replay the moment the buyer chose the other supplier, write the question you should have asked, and practise it out loud. It turns losses into material for competitor objection handling.

A Salesforce survey of 7,775 sales professionals found that only 26% said they receive one-to-one coaching at least weekly. That is a United States survey, not a South African one, but most teams will recognise the gap. A short weekly drill closes it without taking a whole afternoon.

How the 20 minutes run

Minutes What happens What good looks like
0 to 2 Pick the three lost deals. Write the buyer's own words for why they chose the other supplier. Their words, not yours. No guessing.
2 to 8 Deal one: name the value principle they cared about. Write the one question that would have set your standard. A question about support, switching cost or true cost over a year. No rival named.
8 to 14 Deal two: practise the agree and redirect line out loud with a colleague as the buyer. Agrees first, redirects to one thing, mentions what switching involves.
14 to 20 Deal three: replay the whole call from the opening to the next step. Ends with information to send and a set time to talk again.

Spread across the week, short sessions beat one long one. The standard meta-analysis of the spacing effect pooled 839 assessments from 317 experiments, and it is the research behind the idea that practice spread over time sticks better. Most of that work was not done on sellers, so treat it as support for the habit, not a guarantee.

Mark each replay with five questions

Use this short scorecard after each replay. Give one point for each yes, and aim for four or five.

  • Did the seller ask why the buyer chose the current supplier?
  • Did the seller ask how it is going, then stay quiet?
  • Did the seller ask about support, switching cost or the cost over a year, without naming the rival?
  • Did the seller agree first, then redirect to one thing they do better?
  • Did the seller end with a next step, not an attempt to close on the first call?

If you want a fuller form, the sales call scorecard template covers the whole call. Then, for the practice part, run the same lines out loud on the sales call simulator: practise the three standard-setting questions and your agree and redirect line against an AI buyer who says "we're happy with who we have".

A drill note for managers

Keep the tone kind. The point of a lost deal is to learn from it, not to point at the person who lost it. Ask the seller to say what they would ask differently, and let colleagues play the buyer. Rotate the three deals every week so the material stays fresh, and keep a running list of the questions that worked.

What does this approach not solve?

It does not fix a weak offer, a price you cannot justify, or a buyer who has no real reason to change. Questions only help you find a reason that already exists. If the current supplier is genuinely better for this buyer, the honest result is that you lose, and a good seller accepts that and leaves the door open.

It also does not replace the rest of the method. You still need to talk to the right person, earn the right to talk with a proper opening, and show it is safe where safety is a gate. Questions about the current supplier come after that, not instead of it.

A few other limits worth stating plainly:

  • It is not a trick. If you use these questions only to steer the buyer, they will feel it. Ask because you want to know.
  • It cannot make up urgency. A real reason to act now is what waiting costs them, a real date, or a change in their business. Never invent one.
  • It will not win every deal. The method gives you a better standard to compete on, not a guarantee.
  • The research is from elsewhere. Most studies cited here come from the United States and Europe, so use them as a guide and test the approach on your own calls.

How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help

ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. That makes the weekly drill easy to repeat between coaching sessions. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. If you build a sales team, you can practise how to sell against a competitor in Sim Studio and hire from ShiftMate.

Frequently asked questions

Is it ever okay to name a competitor?

Sometimes the buyer names them first. Then use the buyer's own words, ask what they like about them, and keep to questions. Do not criticise. In regulated fields such as financial services, insurance and healthcare, check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business.

What do I say when the buyer says we already have a supplier?

Agree first. Say that makes sense, then ask what made them choose that supplier and how it is going. Once they have told you where it falls short, redirect to the one thing you do better and be honest about what switching involves.

How do I ask why they chose a competitor without sounding nosy?

Ask about the choice, not the fault. A line such as, what made them the right choice at the time, sounds curious and respectful. Then pause and listen. People answer freely when they do not feel judged.

How do I compete without starting a price war?

Move the conversation from the monthly price to the true cost over a year. Ask what the service costs across twelve months once extras, downtime and chasing are counted. Never sell on price alone, because cheaper does not mean better.

How long should the weekly drill take?

Twenty minutes. Use three lost deals: spend about two minutes choosing them, then work through each deal in turn, practising the question and the agree and redirect line out loud. Short, regular sessions are easier to keep up than a long one.

Which of the six value principles should I lead with?

It depends on the buyer's role and industry. Admin and office staff care most about Ease and Speed, finance about Price, Safety and Speed, and owners about Price and Volume. Listen to why they chose their current supplier, because the answer shows which principle matters to them.

What if the buyer asks me directly what is wrong with the other supplier?

Do not run them down. Say you cannot speak for their service, and that you would rather show what you do well. Then ask what matters most to the buyer, and compare your offer with what they use now, using a number or an example.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

See AI sales training

Sources & References

  • https://hbr.org/2006/03/customer-value-propositions-in-business-markets : resonating focus against the customer's next best alternative
  • https://www.bain.com/insights/the-b2b-elements-of-value-hbr/ : buyers weigh up to 40 elements of value
  • https://www.forrester.com/press-newsroom/forrester-the-state-of-business-buying-2024/ : 13 people in a buying decision, 86% stall
  • https://www.salesforce.com/news/stories/sales-research-2023/ : 26% receive weekly one-to-one coaching
  • https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16719566/ : spacing effect meta-analysis

All legal information verified as of 16 November 2026. Consult with a labour lawyer for specific cases.

Keep reading