1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Sales Discovery Questions That Expose Hidden Cost
Sales Training· South Africa

Sales Discovery Questions That Expose Hidden Cost

Sales discovery questions help you find what buyers use now and what it costs them. Get open questions for all six value principles, plus a say-back to use.

··21 min read
Sales professional on a Johannesburg rooftop gesturing at a six-section discovery framework sheet while a prospect leans in, with a cost-calculation flip card visible nearby.

AI-generated

TL;DR: Quick Answer

Sales discovery questions are open questions you ask before any pitch to learn what the buyer uses now and what it costs them in money, time and effort. Ask them under each of the six value principles in the ShiftMate sales training guide, then say back what you heard before you suggest anything.

  • A hidden cost of R400 a month looks small until you say it back as R4,800 a year, and let the buyer confirm the number.
  • Ask about how the work gets done today, not about what is wrong with it. That way nobody has to defend a choice.
  • Practise the questions out loud on AI buyers in ShiftMate Sim Studio until the say-back comes naturally.

Good sales discovery questions find out how the buyer gets the job done today and what that really costs them, without making anyone feel judged. Most buyers have never added the cost up. They know the process is a bit clumsy, but nobody has put a rand figure on it, and until someone does, switching looks like all risk and no gain.

This article teaches step four of Mike Steenkamp's method, prove value with the six value principles, and shows how to ask before you prove. You cannot show a buyer a saving against what they use now if you do not know what they use now. The full eight-step method sits in our sales training guide, and you can practise every question below on the sales call simulator.

Key Takeaways

  • There are six value principles (Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume and Price), so you need at least one open question for each, and a monthly cost turned into a yearly one, such as R1,750 a month becoming R21,000 a year.
  • Ask open questions before any pitch, then say back what you heard in the buyer's own words and ask if you missed anything.
  • ShiftMate Sim Studio lets a sales team practise discovery calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer, and every practice call ends with one thing to fix first.

What are sales discovery questions, and how do they expose hidden cost?

Sales discovery questions are open questions you ask early in a call to learn how the buyer does the job today and what that costs them in time, money, mistakes and stress. A hidden cost is any cost the buyer is paying but has never added up: the two hours a week spent re-capturing orders, the monthly fee for a feature nobody uses, the customer who quietly stopped ordering after a late delivery.

These questions sit after your opening and before your proof. Step two of the method, earn the right to talk, gets you a few minutes. Step three, remember the default answer is no, reminds you why you cannot simply start talking about your product: the buyer is thinking "convince me", and until you show it is good for them, the answer is no.

Discovery is how you earn that proof. When the buyer tells you, in their own words, what the current way costs them, you are no longer arguing. You are only confirming what they already said.

Why open questions come first

An open question cannot be answered with yes or no. "Do you have problems with your current supplier?" invites "No, it's fine." "Walk me through what happens when an order comes in" invites a story, and the story is where the hidden cost lives.

Research on business buying points the same way. Eric Almquist, Jamie Cleghorn and Lori Sherer of Bain & Company, writing in the Harvard Business Review, found that business buyers weigh up to 40 "elements of value". These run from table stakes such as meeting specifications and an acceptable price, through functional and ease-of-doing-business value, to personal concerns such as reduced anxiety and reputational assurance. You can read their work in The B2B Elements of Value. You will not guess which of those matter to this buyer. You have to ask.

The wrong way and the right way

The table below puts a common closed or critical question beside a better open version. It also shows why the better version works.

The wrong way The right way Why it works
"Are you happy with your current supplier?" "How do you order from your supplier today?" It asks for a process, not an opinion, so the buyer has nothing to defend.
"Isn't that system a bit slow?" "How long does it take from start to finish?" The buyer supplies the number, so it is their number and not your claim.
"Why do you still use paper?" "Tell me how the paperwork moves between your team." It removes the word "still", which sounds like blame.
"Would you like to save money?" "What does that cost you in a normal month?" Everyone says yes to the first. Only the second gets a figure you can use.

How do you ask about cost without criticising what they use now?

You ask about the way the work gets done, not about whether it is good, and you treat what they use now as a sensible choice that made sense when they made it. Whoever chose the current supplier, system or process may be sitting in front of you, and nobody agrees to a change while being told they made a mistake.

Four habits keep discovery calm and respectful:

  • Start with "how" and "walk me through". These open a story. "Why" often sounds like an accusation.
  • Be curious about the good parts first. "What do you like about how it works today?" tells you what you must match, and it shows you are not there to attack.
  • Ask about the last time something went wrong. "Think of the last time an order was late. What happened?" is easier to answer than "Do you have delivery problems?"
  • Let silence work. After a question, wait. The most useful answer often arrives after a pause.

Irrelevant questions hurt as much as critical ones. In a 2025 Gartner survey of 632 B2B buyers, mostly in the United States, 73% said they actively avoid suppliers who send irrelevant outreach. The survey was not done in South Africa, but the lesson holds here: do your homework on the company, then ask only what you cannot find out yourself.

Lines you can use to start

These openers are gentle and work for most buyers. Pick the one that suits your product.

  • "Before I tell you anything about us, can I ask how you handle this today?"
  • "Walk me through what happens from the moment you decide you need it to the moment it arrives."
  • "What works well about the way you do it now? I want to make sure we never make that part worse."
  • "If you could change one thing about how it runs, what would it be?"

That last one is a favourite because it lets the buyer name the pain. You are not telling them something is broken. They are telling you.

Which sales discovery questions work for each of the six value principles?

The best sales discovery questions follow the six reasons a business buys: Safety, Quality, Ease, Speed, Volume and Price. In Mike Steenkamp's method, step four is to prove value with these principles, compared with what the buyer uses now and backed with a number or an example. Discovery gives you the "what they use now" and the number. See step four in the guide for how the proof itself is built.

You do not need all six on every call. Which ones you lead with depends on who you are speaking to. The chart below shows what the method says to lead with for each buyer role, so you know which sections of this list to spend your time on.

What to lead with, by the buyer's role

Buyer's roleLead with
Admin and office staffEase, Speed
FinancePrice, Safety, Speed
OwnerPrice, Volume
Marketing and salesVolume, Quality
OperationsSpeed, Ease, Quality
ProcurementPrice, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Read the chart before the call, not during it. An admin clerk does not feel the price, because it is not their money. An owner feels nothing else. The questions below carry the same pattern: ask more under the principles your buyer cares about.

Safety: "What happens if it goes wrong?"

Safety means showing your offer is at least as safe as what they use now. In money, health and data, nothing counts until you do. Discovery tells you how much the buyer already worries about it.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Google (2,156+ Google reviews)

  • "What would happen to your business if this failed for a day?"
  • "Who is responsible when something goes wrong, and what do they have to do?"
  • "What does your team do to double-check the work today?"
  • "How do you keep your customers' information protected at the moment?"

The hidden cost here is often the checking: the manager who re-reads every invoice, the second person who signs off, the backups someone does by hand. That is time paid for every week to avoid a risk. In financial services, insurance, healthcare and software, the method calls this the safety gate. If the buyer is not sure your offer is at least as safe, nothing else you say will count. Where the topic touches a rule or regulation, do not explain it yourself: check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business.

Quality: "What does a good result look like for you?"

Quality means showing a better product, service or result, with a sample or a number. Ask first what "good" means to them, because it is rarely what you assume.

  • "What do you look for when you decide a delivery or a job is good enough?"
  • "How often do you have to send something back or redo it?"
  • "What do your customers say when it is not right?"
  • "What does one mistake cost you, in rand, when it happens?"

The hidden cost under Quality is rework and lost trust. Say a restaurant throws out R1,200 of produce a week because of poor grading is paying R62,400 a year for something it may have stopped noticing.

Ease: "Show me the steps."

Ease means less effort and fewer hassles, shown step by step against how they do it today. You cannot show fewer steps until you have counted their steps.

  • "Take me through each step, from the first email to the money in the bank."
  • "How many people touch it before it is done?"
  • "Which part do people avoid or put off?"
  • "When does someone have to fix it by hand?"

Hours are the hidden cost of Ease. Ask who does the work and roughly what an hour of their time costs the business, then multiply it out. Two hours a week at R180 an hour is R18,720 a year (104 hours at R180).

Speed: "How long does it take, and what happens while you wait?"

Speed means showing the time it saves. "Faster" on its own just gets "Faster than what?" so you need the buyer's current time first.

  • "How long does it take from the first request to the finished result?"
  • "What is waiting on it while it is not done?"
  • "Has a deadline ever been missed because of it? What did that cost?"
  • "Which part of the delay do your customers notice?"

The hidden cost is rarely the wait itself. It is the idle person, the unhappy customer and the late invoice that follow the wait.

Volume: "What would more of it mean for the business?"

Volume means showing how your offer brings in more leads, sales, customers or capacity. It matters most to owners, marketing and sales. Ask what they already have, and what is limiting it.

  • "How many enquiries do you get in a typical month, and how many become customers?"
  • "What stops you from taking on more work?"
  • "What happens to the leads you cannot follow up in time?"
  • "What is one new customer worth to you over a year?"

The hidden cost is the sale you never knew you lost. If a buyer says a customer is worth R30,000 a year and two leads a month go cold, that is R720,000 a year in missed work, and it came from their own numbers, not yours.

Price: "What does this cost you over a year?"

Price means showing it costs less over a year, but never selling on price alone, because cheaper does not mean better. The goal of the question is to find the whole cost, not just the invoice.

  • "What do you pay for this each month, all in?"
  • "Are there extras, call-out fees, top-ups or things you pay for and do not use?"
  • "What does it cost you in staff time to run it?"
  • "When does the contract come up for renewal?"

Always turn the answer into a year. R400 a month sounds like nothing; R4,800 a year gets attention. If the buyer is in admin, be careful: price is not their money, so use Ease and Speed with them and bring Price to the person who pays.

What do you say back after the buyer answers?

You say back, in plain words and the buyer's own numbers, what you heard, then ask whether you got it right. This one habit separates a discovery call from an interview. It proves you listened, it lets the buyer fix mistakes, and it makes the cost theirs.

A simple pattern for the say-back:

  1. Repeat what they do. "So today, orders come in by email and someone types them into the system."
  2. Repeat the cost, in their words. "And you said that takes about four hours a week, and three orders a month go wrong."
  3. Turn it into a year. "That is around 200 hours a year, plus the cost of those mistakes."
  4. Check you got it. "Is that right? Did I miss anything?"

The last question matters most. Buyers often answer with the most important thing they have not told you yet.

Listening carries real weight in selling. A 2023 meta-analysis of 664 effect sizes, led by Avraham Kluger and published in the Journal of Business and Psychology, found a correlation of .39 between being seen as a good listener and work outcomes, with a stronger link to relationship quality (.51) than to performance (.36). It looks at workplaces in general, not only sales, but it fits what a good say-back does for trust.

Do not diagnose and do not pitch yet

When the buyer finishes, resist the urge to say "we can fix that." You have not yet shown you are safe, you have not yet compared yourself with what they use now, and you may not have the right person. Say back, confirm, and only then move on to the proof. Anderson, Narus and van Rossum found, in the Harvard Business Review, that value propositions listing every benefit are weaker than a "resonating focus": the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against their next best alternative and backed with evidence. Discovery is how you find those one or two. Read their work in Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets.

What do two made-up discovery calls sound like?

Two made-up calls follow, with invented names and companies. Neither is a real person, a real business or a real result. The rand amounts are for illustration only.

Example one (made up): office supplies, talking to an admin manager

Grant sells office supplies. He is speaking to Karin Pretorius, the admin manager at Vaalrand Freight Services, an invented transport company. Grant knows the role: admin staff feel Ease and Speed, and price is not their money, so he does not lead with price.

Grant: Karin, before I say anything about us, can I ask how you order stationery and toner today?

Karin: Each department emails me. I collect them, then phone or email three different suppliers.

Grant: Three suppliers. Walk me through what happens after the order goes out.

Karin: Deliveries arrive on different days. I check each one against the order and then match three sets of invoices.

Grant: About how much of your week does that take?

Karin: Probably four hours.

Grant: And when something is missing or wrong?

Karin: I chase it. That is another hour, maybe twice a month.

Grant: Let me say that back. Four hours a week collecting and matching, plus an hour or two a month chasing. That is over 200 hours a year. If I put your time at around R180 an hour, it is about R37,000 a year just in your time. Is that about right, or have I missed something?

Karin: That is about right. I never added it up.

Notice that Grant never said the three-supplier setup was a bad idea. He asked, counted and said it back. Karin gave him the opening: "I never added it up." Now he can move to proof, with steps compared with hers.

Example two (made up): business telecoms, talking to an owner

Priya Naidoo sells business telecoms. She speaks to Johan Venter, the owner of Lowveld Tile Works, an invented company. An owner cares about Price and Volume, so Priya goes for the full cost and for missed calls.

Priya: Johan, what do you pay for phones in a normal month, all in?

Johan: The contract is R2,100.

Priya: And apart from the contract? Does anything else come back to you?

Johan: I give the five reps R350 a month each for airtime on their own phones.

Priya: What happens when a customer calls and nobody picks up?

Johan: They probably call someone else. I don't know how many.

Priya: So the contract is R2,100 and the airtime is R1,750, which is R3,850 a month. Over a year that is R46,200. And you are not sure how many calls go unanswered. Have I got that right?

Johan: That's right. I did not realise it was that much.

Priya's total is only the sum of Johan's own numbers (R2,100 plus R1,750, times twelve). She also found a Volume question to ask later: "What is one new customer worth to you over a year?"

Both calls do the same four things: open question, count, say back as a year, check. If you want more scenarios with scripts, see our sales role play examples.

A look at one South African industry

The weights below are from the method, out of ten, and show how much each principle counts in office supplies. It is a good example because Ease and Price are strong, and a clerk and a finance manager want different things. Use it to decide where your discovery questions should go.

Office supplies: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)

Safety 1
Quality 1
Ease 3
Speed 2
Volume 0
Price 3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

In office supplies, Ease and Price carry most of the weight, so a rep should ask a lot about steps and monthly spend. In financial services or healthcare the same chart shows Safety counting the most. A seller there should start with Safety questions and leave the others until the buyer is comfortable.

Which sales discovery questions can you copy into your next call?

Copy the table below. It is a ready-made set of sales questions to ask, grouped by value principle, with what a good answer sounds like. These discovery call questions work for most business-to-business sales in South Africa. Change the wording to suit your product and your buyer.

Principle Question to ask What good looks like
Safety "What happens if this fails for a day?" The buyer names a real consequence and who pays for it.
Quality "How often do you redo or return it?" A count per week or month, which you can turn into a year.
Ease "Walk me through every step." You can number the steps and name who does each one.
Speed "How long from request to finished?" A time in hours or days, plus what is waiting on it.
Volume "What is one new customer worth over a year?" A rand value for a customer, so lost leads can be priced.
Price "What does it cost you, all in, each month?" A monthly figure including extras, then turned into a year.
Any "Did I miss anything?" (after your say-back) The buyer corrects you or adds one more thing.

A checklist for the call

Print this and keep it beside you on your next call:

  • I opened with who I am, my company and why this matters to them, so I have earned the right to ask questions.
  • I asked at least one open question under the principles that fit this buyer's role.
  • I asked for a number each time: hours, rand, count or days.
  • I turned each monthly figure into a yearly one.
  • I said back what I heard in their words and asked if I missed anything.
  • I did not criticise their current supplier, system or process.
  • I agreed a next step before I hung up.

That last point links to step eight of the method, earn the next step. You do not close on the first call. You agree to send information and a set time to talk again.

How to practise them

Reading a list of questions does not make them stick. Say them out loud. Record yourself or practise with a colleague playing a tough buyer, then use the sales call scorecard template to mark each call. If you are new to calling strangers, the cold calling tips for South Africa are a good place to start before discovery.

What do sales discovery questions not solve?

Sales discovery questions do not close a sale, and they do not fix a bad fit. Be honest about what they cannot do.

  • They do not reach the right person. If you are speaking to someone who does not decide, a perfect discovery call goes nowhere. Step one of the method, talk to the right person, comes first.
  • They do not replace proof. A buyer who confirms R46,200 a year of hidden cost still needs to see that your offer is safe and better. Discovery finds the cost; the six value principles show your answer to it.
  • They do not give you exact numbers. The buyer's figures are estimates. Say so, and check them rather than treating them as fact.
  • They do not remove objections. Expect "we are happy with who we have" anyway. The method's answer, step seven, is agree and redirect, and our page on objection handling has eight answers.
  • They do not create a reason to act now. A real reason, such as what waiting costs, a real date or a change in the business, comes from step six, and it must never be invented.
  • They are not a team-wide answer. Forrester reports that, on average, 13 people in an organisation are involved in a B2B buying decision, and that 86% of B2B purchases stall during the buying process. This is United States and global research, not South African, but it is a reminder that one good conversation rarely settles a sale.

Questions also have limits on a person's patience. If you ask too many in a row, the call starts to feel like a form. Aim for a conversation: one question, one say-back, then the next.

How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help

ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer. Every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first, so a rep can work on a single habit at a time. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. If you want to rehearse the questions in this article, start on the sales call simulator, or see how AI sales training for teams works.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best sales discovery questions to ask?

The best sales discovery questions are open and about how the buyer works today, for example "Walk me through how you handle this now" and "What does that cost you in a normal month?" Ask at least one under each of the six value principles that fit the buyer's role, then say back what you heard before you suggest anything.

How many discovery questions should you ask on a call?

There is no magic number, but aim for a conversation, not a form. A good rule is one open question, then a say-back, then the next question. If you find yourself on question eight with no say-back, stop and confirm what you have heard so far.

How do you ask about cost without sounding critical?

Ask about the process, not about whether it is good. Say "How does it work today?" instead of "Why do you still do it that way?" Treat the current supplier or system as a reasonable choice, and let the buyer name the problems themselves.

What is a hidden cost in sales?

A hidden cost is something the buyer pays for in time, money, mistakes or stress but has never added up. Examples are hours spent on manual admin, fees for unused features, rework, and customers lost after a late delivery. Your job is to help the buyer see it by asking, counting and saying it back.

Should you pitch during discovery?

No. Pitching too early makes the buyer defensive and tells them you were not listening. Ask open questions, say back what you heard, and confirm it. Only then move to showing value against what they use now, with a number or an example to back it up.

Which discovery questions work best for an admin clerk or an owner?

With admin and office staff, ask about steps, hassles and time, because Ease and Speed are what they feel daily, and price is not their money. With an owner, ask about monthly cost and about what a new customer is worth, because Price and Volume matter most to them.

How do you practise discovery call questions?

Say them out loud, with feedback, until the wording is natural. Practise with a colleague, score yourself with a call scorecard, or use ShiftMate Sim Studio to rehearse on an AI buyer built from your own offer, where each practice call ends with a report and one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

See AI sales training

Sources & References

  • https://www.bain.com/insights/the-b2b-elements-of-value-hbr/ - buyers weigh up to 40 elements of value
  • https://hbr.org/2006/03/customer-value-propositions-in-business-markets - resonating focus
  • https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2025-06-25-gartner-sales-survey-finds-61-percent-of-b2b-buyers-prefer-a-rep-free-buying-experience - 73% avoid irrelevant outreach
  • https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10869-023-09897-5 - listening meta-analysis
  • https://www.forrester.com/press-newsroom/forrester-the-state-of-business-buying-2024/ - 13 people in a buying decision

All legal information verified as of 16 November 2026. Consult with a labour lawyer for specific cases.

Keep reading