TL;DR: Quick Answer
Insurance sales role play means practising seven realistic phone calls out loud: too expensive, already has cover, wants to ask a spouse, distrusts phone sales, wants to think, asks something you cannot answer, and wants to cancel. Practise the honest, unhurried way, and check every line with your compliance person first.
Each scenario below shows the wrong way beside the right way, with word-for-word lines, using made-up rand amounts such as R180 a month, which is R2,160 a year.
In insurance, safety counts for 4 points out of 10, so every script is built to show the caller you are straight with them before you talk about anything else.
Next step: pick one scenario, practise it out loud three times, and have your compliance person read the lines before anyone uses them on a real call.
Insurance sales role play is where a seller practises a hard call out loud, against someone playing the caller, before the real caller ever picks up. This article gives you seven made-up calls for life, funeral and short-term cover. It teaches one step of Mike Steenkamp's method, step five, show it's safe , from the sales training guide and its six value principles.
Every example is a practice line, not advice on what to say on a live call. This article states no rules of any kind. Before you use any line, check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business. Then check your own policy wording, because no script here promises what any policy does.
Key Takeaways
In insurance, the method gives safety 4 points out of 10, price 2, ease 2, quality 1, speed 1 and volume 0. That is why a calm, straight answer beats a clever one.
Seven scenarios, each with a wrong way and a right way. The right way is always honest, unhurried and free of pressure, and it points the caller back to their own policy wording.
ShiftMate Sim Studio lets a team practise calls like these out loud on AI buyers, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.
What is insurance sales role play, and how do you run it?
Insurance sales role play is a practice call where one person plays the seller and another plays the caller, using a scenario card. It works because insurance objections are emotional as well as practical. A caller who says "it's too expensive" is often also saying "I am afraid of being cheated". You cannot learn to answer that from a slide.
Good insurance sales training gives you a method you can explain in a sentence, then makes you practise it out loud, with feedback, until it sticks. The method here has eight steps in call order. The step this article teaches is the fifth: show it's safe. In financial services, insurance, healthcare and software, nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is at least as safe as what they have now.
Here is the simple way to run a session with a team of any size:
Pair people up. One plays the seller, one plays the caller, and a third (if you have one) watches with the scorecard.
Hand over a scenario card. It says who the caller is, what they say first and what is worrying them underneath.
Run the call for about four minutes. Stop at the objection and play it twice: the wrong way first, then the right way.
Give one piece of feedback. Not five. One thing to fix, then run it again.
Swap roles. Playing the caller teaches a seller more about pressure than any lecture.
Spacing matters too. A large review of spacing (distributed practice) pooled 839 assessments from 317 experiments in 184 articles. That research is from laboratory studies, mostly outside South Africa, so treat it as a reason to practise a little often, not as a promise about any one team.
For more on making practice stick, read How to Practise Sales Calls So It Sticks .
Why does safety come first in insurance sales training?
Safety comes first because the caller is handing you a promise about their family's worst day. They will not weigh price or speed until they feel safe with you and with what you are describing. In the method's industry weights, insurance scores 4 for safety, 1 for quality, 2 for ease, 1 for speed, 0 for volume and 2 for price, and safety is a gate.
Insurance: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)
Safety
4
Quality
1
Ease
2
Speed
1
Volume
0
Price
2
Safety gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is safe.
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
"Gate" means nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is safe. On a phone call, safety is mostly about how you behave. Do you rush? Do you dodge a question? Do you promise things the policy wording might not say? A caller can hear all of that in about thirty seconds.
The research on business buying points the same way. Bain's work on the B2B elements of value shows that buyers weigh table stakes first, then functional value, then personal concerns such as reduced anxiety. You can read it in The B2B Elements of Value in the Harvard Business Review. It studies business buyers, not households, but "reduced anxiety" is exactly what a nervous caller is shopping for.
The method also says to remember the default answer is no. The buyer is thinking "convince me". Until you show it is good for them, and safe for them, the answer stays no. Insurance callers have often been called before, so the "no" can come fast.
The three habits behind every right-way script
Honest. Say what you know, say what you do not, and never fill the gap with a guess.
Unhurried. Leave a pause after an objection. Silence is not a threat to the sale.
No pressure. If you give a reason to act now, it is a real one. Never invented urgency. See How to Create Urgency in Sales Without Pressure .
One more habit sits under all three: agree first, then redirect. That is step seven of the method, and the guide explains it under agree and redirect . For eight worked answers, see objection handling .
Insurance sales role play scenarios 1 to 3: price, existing cover and a spouse
These first three are the most common. They are also where a rushed seller does the most damage. All names and the company in these scenarios are made up. Veldrift Cover is an invented company, and every rand amount is invented for practice.
Scenario 1: "It's too expensive"
Scenario card (made up). Johan van Rooyen, 44, has been quoted R180 a month for a funeral plan for his family. He goes quiet, then says the price is too high. Underneath, he is not sure what he would get for his money.
Wrong way Right way
"It's actually very cheap for what you get. Most people pay more. Shall I sign you up today before the price changes?"
"I hear you, R180 a month is a real amount. That is R2,160 over a year. Can I ask what you pay now, and what you want the cover to do for your family? Then we can look at your own policy wording together and see whether it fits."
Why the right way works. It agrees first, then redirects. It turns a monthly figure into a yearly one, so Johan can compare it with what he spends today. It asks before it tells. For more on this, read How to Handle Price Objections Without Discounting .
The wrong way does three bad things at once. It brushes off the feeling, it makes a claim about "what you get" without pointing to any wording, and it adds a deadline that nobody has shown to be real.
Say this aloud: "I'm not going to tell you what it covers from memory. Check your own policy wording, and I'll go through it with you line by line."
Scenario 2: "I already have cover"
Scenario card (made up). Karin Botha, 52, says she already has a policy through her employer and another one she took years ago. She is polite but ready to end the call.
Wrong way Right way
"Your old cover is probably useless. Those old policies never pay out. Ours is much better."
"That's good to hear, Karin, it means you've already thought about this. I'm not asking you to drop anything. Would it help to have a quick look at what you have now, and I'll tell you honestly if I see nothing that we do better?"
Why the right way works. The wrong way attacks something the caller chose, and it states something nobody on the call has checked. The right way is the method's "agree and redirect", plus honesty about what switching involves. Honest about what switching involves means you do not hide that changing cover has consequences, and you tell her to read her own policy wording before she changes anything.
Practise a second version where the caller has nothing in writing in front of her. The right-way line becomes: "No problem. Could you find the paperwork later and call me back, or shall I phone you at a time that suits? Please check your own policy wording before you decide anything." This is the same idea as 'We're Happy With Our Current Supplier': What to Say , moved from business buying to a household.
Scenario 3: "I need to ask my husband"
Scenario card (made up). Priya Naidoo, 38, likes what she hears about short-term cover for her car, but says she cannot decide without her husband, Ravi.
Wrong way Right way
"Surely you can make this decision yourself? Just say yes now and tell him later."
"Of course, it's a decision for the two of you. Would it help if I send you the details in writing, and we agree a time when you and Ravi can both be on the phone? I'll answer his questions too."
Why the right way works. A shared decision is not a stall. The method says you do not close on the first call. You earn the next step: agree to send information and a set time to talk again. Notice the right-way line names a time, not just "I'll call you sometime". See Sales Follow-Up Call: What to Say and When for how to make that second call count.
Say this aloud: "Please read the policy wording together, and bring any questions to our next call."
Insurance role play scenarios 4 and 5: trust and "let me think about it"
These two are about trust and time. They are the calls where an unhurried seller wins by doing less.
Scenario 4: "I don't trust phone sales"
Scenario card (made up). Grant Pillay, 61, says he has heard stories about people being sold things over the phone and he does not do business this way.
Wrong way Right way
"I'm a professional, sir, you can trust me. Everybody says that and then they sign up. Let me just take your details."
"That's fair, Grant, and you are right to be careful. I'm not going to ask you for anything today. I'll tell you who I am, who I work for and how I got your number, and you can check all of it before we speak again. Would that be okay?"
Why the right way works. This is the opening checklist in action: who you are, your company, how you got their details, what you want and why it matters to them. Say it clearly and early, and offer the caller a way to check you. The checklist is worth 10 points. Seven of ten is a good opening, and a tough buyer needs eight or nine.
The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)
Who you are
1
Your company
1
What your company does (must be said)
0
What the call is about
2
How you got their details
1
What you want from this call
2
Why it matters to them
3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
Look at where the points sit. "Why it matters to them" is worth the most, 3 points. "What your company does" is worth 0, because it is said but earns nothing on its own. In a trust scenario, "how you got their details" is worth 1 point and does most of the work. Callers who suspect phone sales want that answer first. Gartner found that 73% of B2B buyers say they actively avoid suppliers who send irrelevant outreach (Gartner, 2025, a survey of business buyers in the United States and elsewhere, not a South African household figure). The lesson carries over: relevance and openness earn you the next minute.
Practise this one with the caller playing a hard "no" until the seller has said all seven opening points. For a longer treatment of openings, see Cold Call Script: 5 Fill-In Openings That Work .
Say this aloud: "Don't take my word for it. Check your own policy wording, and call the number on your paperwork if you want to confirm anything I've said."
Scenario 5: "Let me think about it"
Scenario card (made up). Sarah Jacobs, 29, is interested in life cover but says she will think about it. The seller senses the call is slipping away.
Wrong way Right way
"What is there to think about? This offer ends today, and you will regret it if something happens."
"Sure, take your time, Sarah. Can I ask what you'd like to think through? If it's the price or the wording, I can send both in writing. Shall we set a time on Thursday for a short call, and you tell me what you decided?"
Why the right way works. The wrong way uses fear and a made-up deadline. That is exactly what the method rules out: a real reason to act now means what waiting costs them, a real date, or a change in their business, never invented urgency. The right way asks one open question, offers the thing a thinker actually needs (the details in writing) and agrees a set time.
"Let me think about it" is rarely about thinking. It usually hides one of the other scenarios in this article: price, trust, a spouse or a question the caller does not want to ask. A good question gently finds out which. For question ideas, see Sales Discovery Questions That Expose Hidden Cost .
Say this aloud: "When you read the policy wording, mark anything that isn't clear and we'll go through it on Thursday."
Insurance sales role play scenarios 6 and 7: the unknown answer and the cancellation
The last two scenarios are where a seller's honesty is tested hardest. They are also the calls that decide whether a customer ever speaks to you again.
Scenario 6: a question you cannot answer
Scenario card (made up). Ravi Moodley, 47, asks a detailed question about how a particular situation would be handled under the plan. The seller does not know the answer.
Wrong way Right way
"Yes, that's definitely covered, don't worry about it."
"That's a good question, Ravi, and I don't want to guess. I don't know the answer to that one. Let me find out from the right person, and I'll call you back by Wednesday at 10:00 with the answer in writing. Please also check your own policy wording."
Why the right way works. It says "I don't know", it names who will answer, and it sets a time to call back. The seller then has to keep that promise, because a missed callback is worse than the original gap. This is the single best habit in this article: say you will find out and call back, and then do it.
The wrong way is dangerous for everyone. It invents an answer about what a policy does, and a caller may act on it. Never promise what a policy or product does. Pass the question to the person in your business who owns the answer, and confirm it in writing.
Run this scenario three times in a row, with the caller asking a harder question each time. The seller's job is to stay calm and say the same honest thing. For the listening side of this, read Active Listening in Sales: What It Sounds Like .
Say this aloud: "I'll confirm that in writing, and please check your own policy wording too, so we are both reading the same words."
Scenario 7: "I want to cancel"
Scenario card (made up). Johan van Rooyen from Scenario 1 phones back, three months later, to cancel his R180 a month plan because money is tight. The seller is tempted to talk him out of it.
Wrong way Right way
"You can't cancel now, you'll lose everything you paid in. Let me transfer you to someone who will talk you out of it."
"I'm sorry to hear money is tight, Johan. Thank you for telling me. Before we go further, can I ask what has changed? I'll explain how cancelling works in your business as I understand it, and I'll check the detail against your own policy wording and with my team so I don't get it wrong."
Why the right way works. It starts with the person, not the policy. It asks what changed, because the real reason may be something you can help with honestly, such as a lower-priced option. It does not claim anything about what he would lose or keep. The detail goes to the person in your business who knows it.
Retention is a different skill from a first sale, and it has its own article: Customer Retention Call Script: Saving a Cancellation . Whatever you decide to say on a cancellation call, check the wording with the person responsible for compliance in your business first.
Say this aloud: "If you do decide to cancel, I'll make it easy and tell you what happens next. Please check your own policy wording as well."
Which scripts can you start with: a funeral cover sales script and an insurance sales script?
You can start with the right-way lines above, once your compliance person has read them. A funeral cover sales script and a general insurance sales script share the same spine. Open clearly, ask before you tell, give the number in yearly terms, and point the caller to their own wording.
Here is a short, made-up funeral cover sales script opening for practice. The company, Veldrift Cover, is invented.
"Good afternoon, Mrs Botha. This is Sarah Jacobs from Veldrift Cover. We help families plan for funeral costs. I'm calling because you asked us for a quote on our website on Monday, and I'd like to ask three short questions to see whether a plan would suit your family. Is now an okay time? If it isn't, I'll call you when it is."
"I won't tell you what any plan covers from memory. I'll send you the details in writing, and you can check your own policy wording before you decide anything."
Count the opening checklist points in that opening. Who you are: Sarah Jacobs. Your company: Veldrift Cover. What it does: planning for funeral costs. What the call is about: the quote request. How you got the details: the website request. What you want: three short questions. Why it matters to them: the family. That is every point, and it takes about twenty seconds.
Use the same spine for an insurance sales script on short-term cover. Swap the family for the car, the home or the trip, keep the questions short, and keep the same closing line. If you want more script shapes, the telesales script examples show how to lay one out.
A checklist to copy for every practice call
Print this and tick it during each practice call. It is yours to copy.
What to check What good looks like
The opening All seven opening points said in the first 30 seconds, including why it matters to them.
The pause At least two seconds of quiet after the objection, before the seller speaks.
Agree first The seller agrees with the feeling before redirecting.
No promises Nothing said about what a policy does. "Check your own policy wording" is said at least once.
The unknown "I don't know" is said plainly, with a named person and a time to call back.
The next step The call ends with information to be sent and a set time to talk again.
You can turn that checklist into a scored sheet with the sales call scorecard template .
How do you score an insurance sales role play?
You score an insurance sales role play by listening for behaviour, not for the script word for word. Did the seller stay honest, unhurried and free of pressure? Did the caller feel safer at the end than at the start? Those two questions are worth more than any tick box.
The sales method: eight steps, in call order
Talk to the right person Earn the right to talk Remember the default answer is no Prove value with the six value principles Show it's safe Give a real reason to act now Agree and redirect Earn the next step
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
Use the eight steps as a lens. Was it the right person? Did the seller earn the right to talk? Did they remember the default answer is no? Did they prove value with the six value principles, and then show it is safe? Did they give a real reason to act now, agree and redirect, and earn the next step? A call can go wrong at any of those, and naming the step makes the feedback specific.
The research on value propositions supports keeping it simple. Anderson, Narus and van Rossum found that value propositions that list every benefit are weaker than a "resonating focus": the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against their next best alternative and backed with evidence. You can read it in Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets . For a caller worried about being cheated, that focus is usually safety, then price, and nothing more on a first call.
Three scoring traps for managers
What does insurance sales role play not solve? What this does not solve
Insurance sales role play does not tell you what you can say, and it does not replace the people in your business who know. It is practice for how you say things, not a source of rules. Every line in this article needs to be checked by the person responsible for compliance in your business before a seller uses it on a real call.
It also does not fix a product that is a poor fit. If the cover does not suit the caller, no script will make it honest to sell. And it does not fix a weak list, an unclear offer or a team that never gets time to practise. A Salesforce survey of 7,775 sales professionals (a survey from 2022, not a South African one) found that reps spend just 28% of their week actually selling, so practice time has to be protected on purpose.
Finally, role play does not prove that sellers will do the right thing on a live call. It raises the odds. To find out what actually happens, you also need to listen to real calls, and to ask your compliance person what to look for.
Here is the honest summary. Practise to build habits: pause, agree, ask, say "I don't know", and send things in writing. Check with your compliance person for everything that touches a rule. Check your own policy wording for everything that touches what a policy does.
How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help
ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. You can try the sales call simulator to practise the objections in this article. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. For more drills, see sales role play examples .
Frequently asked questions
What is insurance sales role play?
Insurance sales role play is practising a phone call out loud, with one person as the seller and one as the caller, before a real call happens. It is used to build habits such as pausing, agreeing first and saying "I don't know". Check every line with your compliance person before using it.
How many scenarios should a team practise in a session?
One or two scenarios, played several times each, is better than all seven once. Run a call for about four minutes, give one piece of feedback, and run it again. Short, repeated sessions help skills stick better than one long workshop.
What should I say when a caller asks something I cannot answer?
Say plainly that you do not know, name who will find out, and give a time to call back, then keep that promise. Do not guess about what a policy does. Ask the caller to check their own policy wording, and confirm your answer in writing.
How do I handle "I already have cover" without attacking it?
Agree first. Say it is good they have thought about it, say you are not asking them to drop anything, and ask what they have now. Tell them to read their own policy wording before changing anything, and check your lines with your compliance person.
Is a funeral cover sales script different from other insurance scripts?
The spine is the same: a clear opening, questions before answers, yearly numbers, and a pointer to the caller's own policy wording. The words around it change with the product. Your compliance person needs to approve the final wording before any seller uses it.
How do I practise the cancellation call?
Start with the person, not the policy. Thank them, ask what has changed, and explain what happens next only after checking the detail with your team and the policy wording. Run it as a role play and check the lines with your compliance person.
How do I know if my insurance sales training is working?
Look at behaviour on practice and real calls: complete openings, a pause after objections, honest "I don't know" answers and a set next step. Score the same few things each week and compare. Ask your compliance person what else to review.
ShiftMate Sim Studio
Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no
Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.
See AI sales training