1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. How to Sell Financial Services Over the Phone
Sales Training· South Africa

How to Sell Financial Services Over the Phone

Learn how to sell financial services over the phone: show it is safe first, put value in rand over a year and earn the next step, with scripts you can practise.

··19 min read
Business professional standing at a city office building entrance speaking on a phone while holding a document displaying a large rand value figure and bar chart.

AI-generated

TL;DR: Quick Answer

To sell financial services over the phone, show the buyer it is at least as safe as what they use now before you talk about anything else. Say only true facts about your own business, put the value in rand over a year, and agree a next step instead of pushing for a close.

  • In financial services, safety counts 4 out of 10 and is a gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure. Ease is 3, speed 2, price 1.
  • Compare the cost over a year, for example R1,850 a month is R22,200, so the buyer sees one number they can check.
  • Before you use any line from this article, check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business, then practise it out loud.

If you want to know how to sell financial services over the phone, start with one idea: the buyer is not asking whether your offer is good. They are asking whether it is safe. That is the fifth step in the safety gate step of the sales training guide, and in financial services nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is at least as safe as what they have today.

This article is for people in South Africa who sell, or manage people who sell. It teaches the safety gate on Mike Steenkamp's six value principles. It gives you word-for-word lines, a script, a scorecard and two made-up example calls. It does not tell you what any rule says. Whatever you plan to say, check it with the person responsible for compliance in your business first.

Key Takeaways

  • Safety is worth 4 out of 10 in financial services, more than any other reason to buy, and ease is next at 3.
  • Show safety with three true facts about your own business: who you are, where the money sits and who else uses you. Never promise what a product does.
  • ShiftMate Sim Studio lets your team practise these calls out loud on AI buyers, with one thing to fix first after every call.

How to sell financial services when the buyer's first question is "is it safe?"

The usual advice on how to sell financial services is borrowed from other industries. Most sales training says: build rapport, find the pain, show the benefit. In financial services that order breaks down. The person on the other end is thinking about their money, their staff's money or their business's cash. A friendly voice does not move that to the front of the queue.

The method has eight steps in call order. Safety is step five, but it shapes everything before it. Here are the steps, so you can see where this article sits.

The sales method: eight steps, in call order

  1. Talk to the right person
  2. Earn the right to talk
  3. Remember the default answer is no
  4. Prove value with the six value principles
  5. Show it's safe
  6. Give a real reason to act now
  7. Agree and redirect
  8. Earn the next step
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Step three is the one to hold in your head all call: the buyer's default answer is no. They are thinking "convince me". In financial services, the first thing to convince them of is that you will not put them at risk.

Buyers feel this even before you speak. Research on business buying shows that buyers weigh many kinds of value, from basic needs to personal ones such as less anxiety. See Almquist, Cleghorn and Sherer (Bain & Company), "The B2B Elements of Value", Harvard Business Review, 2018. Anxiety about money is real, and you are the person who has just interrupted their day.

Why does safety come before everything else in financial services?

Safety comes first because a business buyer who is unsure about safety cannot hear the rest. A lower fee, a faster process or a nicer portal means nothing if they think they might lose money or look foolish to their own boss.

The method puts numbers on this. Out of 10, financial services is weighted like this: Safety 4, Quality 0, Ease 3, Speed 2, Volume 0, Price 1. It is marked as a safety gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is safe.

Financial services: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)

Safety 4
Quality 0
Ease 3
Speed 2
Volume 0
Price 1

Safety gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is safe.

Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Read the chart honestly, because it changes how to sell financial services compared with, say, office supplies. Price is only 1 out of 10. That does not mean price never comes up. It means that if you lead with a cheaper fee, you are leading with the thing that counts least. Quality and volume are 0 in this industry, so claims such as "better returns" or "more clients for your business" are the wrong place to spend your time on a first call.

What the gate looks like on a call

The gate is not a speech. It is the moment the buyer's tone changes from "tell me more" to "OK, I'm listening". Before it, they answer in short sentences and look for a way off the call. After it, they ask about the admin, the timing and the cost.

Your job is to get through the gate fast and honestly. That means answering the safety question before they have to ask it.

Who you are talking to changes what you lead with

The buyer's role changes the second and third reasons to buy. A finance buyer is worth leading with Price, Safety and Speed. An owner wants Price and Volume. Admin and office staff care most about Ease and Speed, and should never be led with Price because it is not their money. In financial services, safety still sits in front of all of them.

What to lead with, by the buyer's role

Buyer's roleLead with
Admin and office staffEase, Speed
FinancePrice, Safety, Speed
OwnerPrice, Volume
Marketing and salesVolume, Quality
OperationsSpeed, Ease, Quality
ProcurementPrice, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

If you are selling to a finance director, read how to sell to a financial director alongside this article. They carry the risk, so the gate is where the call is won or lost.

How do you show it is safe when you sell financial services?

You show it is safe by saying three true things about your own business, plainly, and then stopping. The three are who you are, where the money sits and who else uses you. Each one is a fact the buyer can check. Say nothing you cannot back up.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Google (2,156+ Google reviews)

Here is what each one means as a spoken line. The square brackets are blanks that only your business can fill, with facts that are true for you.

  • Who you are: "I'm Sarah Whitfield from [your company]. We've been [how long, only if true] doing [what you actually do]."
  • Where the money sits: "Your money is held by [the institution that holds it, only if true]. I'm happy to send you that in writing so you can check it."
  • Who else uses you: "We work with [a type of business, only if true, and only if you are free to say so]. If you'd like, I can ask whether one of them is happy to talk to you."

Notice what is missing. There is no "completely safe", no "you can't lose" and no "guaranteed". Those words put you in a spot you cannot get out of. Never promise what a policy or product does. When the buyer asks what it covers or pays, the honest answer is the same every time: "Check your own policy wording. I'll send you the wording so you can read it for yourself."

Before using any of these three lines, check with the person responsible for compliance in your business what you can say, and how you can say it. That one conversation is worth more than any script. Your business may need these lines worded differently, and that person will know.

The wrong way beside the right way

What sellers say Why it fails What good looks like
"It's completely safe." A promise you cannot back, and the buyer knows it. "Here is who holds the money. I'll send it in writing."
"Everyone uses us." Vague, and impossible to check. "We work with [a type of business, only if true]."
"It will pay out if something goes wrong." Promises what the product does. "Check your own policy wording. I'll send it so you can read it."
"Trust me." Asks for faith when the buyer wants facts. "Don't take my word for it. Here's how you can check."
Talks fees before safety. Leads with the lowest-weighted reason to buy. Answers who, where and who else first, then moves to cost.

The pattern in the right-hand column is the same every time. You hand the buyer a way to check. A buyer who can check things stops defending and starts listening, which is exactly what the gate is for.

How do you open a financial services call so the buyer stays on the line?

You open with seven things, in under half a minute, and the one worth the most is why the call matters to them. This is step two of the method, earn the right to talk. In financial services, a vague or pushy opening makes the buyer start the safety question before you have answered it.

The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)

Who you are 1
Your company 1
What your company does (must be said) 0
What the call is about 2
How you got their details 1
What you want from this call 2
Why it matters to them 3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Seven out of 10 is a good opening. A tough buyer needs eight or nine. Notice that "what your company does" is worth 0. You still have to say it, but it earns nothing on its own. "Why it matters to them" is worth 3, so most of your opening time belongs there.

Example call 1 (made up): the opening

Sarah Whitfield works for a made-up company, Hennig Brook Financial. She is calling Johan Strydom, the owner of a made-up cold storage business, Strydom Cold Storage. All names are invented.

Sarah: "Good morning, Johan, it's Sarah Whitfield from Hennig Brook Financial. We help small businesses with their staff benefit administration. I'm calling about how you handle that paperwork each month. I found your number on your website. I'd like two minutes to ask a couple of questions and, if it makes sense, book a proper talk. The reason I'm calling is that owners tell me the monthly admin takes a lot of their time and they worry about getting it wrong. Is now a bad time?"

That opening scores well: who she is (1), her company (1), what it does (0), what the call is about (2), how she got his details (1), what she wants (2) and why it matters to him (3). That is the full 10 out of 10. Real calls will not always hit every point, but a seven is a good opening.

Johan has not asked a question about safety yet. Sarah answers it anyway, in the next breath. That is the next section.

Example call 1 (made up): going through the gate

Johan: "I have a provider already. Why would I look at someone else?"

Sarah: "Fair question. Before anything else, here is who we are and how you can check us. I'm with Hennig Brook Financial. [Where the money sits, said only if true and approved by your compliance person.] [Who else uses us, said only if true.] I'll send both to you in writing so you don't have to take my word for it. And if you ask what a product pays or covers, my answer will always be: check your own policy wording. I'll send you the wording to read."

She has not promised a thing. She has told him who she is, where to look and how to check. If you want to practise this exact moment, the sales call simulator lets you say it out loud to an AI buyer who pushes back, so you hear how it sounds before a real buyer does.

How to sell financial services with the value shown in rand over a year

Once the buyer is sure it is safe, you move to the next reasons to buy: ease (3), speed (2) and price (1). The step is proving value with the six value principles, and it works only if you compare against what they use now and back it with a number.

Put the number in rand and over a year. A monthly amount feels small and easy to ignore. A year feels like a real cost, and it is the number a finance person puts on a page.

Example call 2 (made up): ease and cost in rand

Karin Botha is the office manager at a made-up business, Botha & Sons Packaging. She is speaking to Ravi Pillay, who works for a made-up company, Lakeview Financial Partners. All numbers below are invented for the example.

Ravi: "Karin, you said you spend about six hours a month on the benefit paperwork. What is your time worth, roughly, per hour?"

Karin: "I suppose around R180 an hour, all in."

Ravi: "So six hours is R1,080 a month, which is R12,960 over a year, just in your time. You also told me your current provider charges R1,850 a month in admin fees. That is R22,200 a year. If our fee is R1,600 a month, that is R19,200 a year, so R3,000 less. Before you take that as a promise: check your own policy wording and the fee schedule I'll send, so you can confirm every figure yourself."

Look at what Ravi did. He asked Karin for her own numbers, did the sum out loud, compared a year against a year and handed her the paperwork to check. He did not say the product was better, because quality is 0 in this industry. He showed less effort and less cost, and he kept the buyer in charge.

A note on the numbers: they are made up. Use your own, from your own fee schedule, and have the person responsible for compliance in your business check how you describe them.

Keep the proof short

Research on business value propositions finds that listing every benefit is weaker than choosing the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against their next best alternative and backed with evidence. See Anderson, Narus and van Rossum, "Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets", Harvard Business Review, 2006.

For financial services, that usually means two things: a clear safety answer, then either ease or cost. If you are not sure which, ask a good question. Sales discovery questions that expose hidden cost has examples you can adapt.

How do you handle objections in financial services?

You agree with the objection, then redirect to what you do better, and you are honest about what switching involves. This is step seven, agree and redirect. In financial services, the commonest objection is a safety question in disguise.

Here are three common ones, with a line you can practise. Each is a starting point only. Check the wording with the person responsible for compliance in your business before you use it.

  • "We already have a provider." "That makes sense, and you should not move without a reason. Let me show you how we compare on the admin and the cost over a year. Then it is your call."
  • "I don't know you." "You're right not to. That's why I'd rather send you who we are and where the money sits in writing, and you can check it before we talk again."
  • "Is it cheaper?" "It might be for you, and I'd rather show you the numbers over a year than guess. Never choose on price alone, though, so we'll look at the admin side too."

Be straight about the cost of switching. Honest objection handling is part of how to sell financial services to a careful buyer. Moving takes the buyer's time, and a good seller says so. For more answers to practise, see the objection handling guide with eight answers.

How to sell financial services and earn the next step

You do not close on the first call. Step eight is earn the next step: agree to send information and a set time to talk again. In financial services this is not a weak ending. It gives the buyer time to check the three facts, and they will.

Buyers are rarely alone, so how to sell financial services includes making your message easy to pass on. Forrester reports that on average 13 people in an organisation are involved in a B2B buying decision, and 86% of B2B purchases stall during the buying process. That research is from the United States and Europe, not South Africa, but it fits what many sellers see: the person on your call usually has to take your answer to someone else.

So the next step should be easy to pass along. Send the written facts, the fee schedule and the policy wording, and book the follow-up before you hang up.

A script for the close of the call

Use this, with your own details in the brackets:

  1. "Let me sum up what I heard: [the buyer's own words, with their numbers]."
  2. "I'll send you three things today: who we are, where the money sits and the fee schedule, plus the policy wording to read for yourself."
  3. "Who else needs to see this before you decide?"
  4. "Can we book 15 minutes on [day and time] to go through your questions?"
  5. "I'll send a calendar invite now, and I'll call you at that time."

If the buyer does not pick up that follow-up, read sales follow-up call: what to say and when. For getting the first meeting booked, see how to book a sales meeting on a first call.

A reason to move now, never an invented one

Step six is a real reason to move now: what waiting costs them, a real date or a change in their business. Never invent urgency. If there is no real reason, do not make one up. Use the plain close above instead. A buyer in financial services will notice pressure and walk away from it. Read how to create urgency in sales without pressure for honest ways to do it.

How do you practise financial services sales tips so they stick?

You practise them out loud, on a buyer who pushes back, with feedback, again and again. Reading is not practice. If you are building financial services sales training for a team, the order matters: the three safety lines first, then the rand-over-a-year sum, then the close.

Here is a short scorecard a manager can copy. Listen to a real or practice call and tick each line.

What to listen for What good looks like
Safety answered before price Who you are, where the money sits and who else uses you are all said, as true facts.
No promises about the product "Check your own policy wording" is said, and the wording is offered.
Opening checklist At least seven out of 10, and why it matters to them said clearly.
Value in rand The buyer's own numbers, compared over a year against what they use now.
Objection handled Agree first, then redirect, and honest about what switching involves.
Next step agreed Information sent and a time set to talk again before the call ends.

For a fuller version, use the sales call scorecard template. For a plan that brings a new person up to speed, see the new sales rep 30-day plan.

Practice that is spread over weeks beats one big session. A large analysis of the spacing effect, pooling 839 assessments from 317 experiments in 184 articles, supports short, repeated practice (Cepeda and others, Psychological Bulletin, 2006, source). That is general learning research, not a South African or sales-specific finding. For how to make it stick, read how to practise sales calls so it sticks.

One more South African reality check

Many South African buyers have been called by a provider they have never heard of, so your voice may be the fourth or fifth of the week. A short, honest, checkable opening stands out from that noise. If you also need a script for a first call, see telesales script examples.

What this does not solve

This method will not make a buyer who is not a fit say yes. If the company is not the right size or type, or you are not speaking to the person who decides, no safety line will fix that. Step one, talking to the right person, still comes first.

It will not tell you what to say for your business. This article names no rule, and it cannot know your business, your products or what applies to you. Whatever you plan to say about safety, cost or what a product does, check it with the person responsible for compliance in your business before you say it on a call. Ask them to approve your three safety lines and your follow-up wording.

It will not make a weak product strong. If your product is not at least as safe as what the buyer has, honest selling will tell you so, which is a useful thing to learn early. And it will not replace practice. Knowing the lines is not the same as saying them calmly to a doubtful stranger. Only practising out loud does that.

Finally, how to sell financial services is a process over several calls, and one call will rarely finish the job. Many buyers take weeks, ask others, and stall. The aim of a first call is a good second call.

How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help

ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer. Every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first, so a rep knows what to work on next. You can see how it works in the AI sales training for teams page.

ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. If you are growing a team that makes these calls, you can start there.

Frequently asked questions

What is the first thing to do when selling financial services by phone?

Answer the safety question before the buyer asks it. Say who you are, where the money sits and who else uses you, as true facts about your own business, and offer to send them in writing. Check the wording with the person responsible for compliance in your business first.

Why does price count for so little in financial services?

In the method's weights for financial services, price is 1 out of 10 and safety is 4. A buyer worried about their money will not hear a lower fee until they are sure it is safe. Show safety first, then compare cost over a year.

Can I tell a buyer what a policy or product will do?

Do not promise what a product does. Say "check your own policy wording" and send the wording so the buyer can read it. Before you describe any product on a call, check what you can say with the person responsible for compliance in your business.

How do I put value in rand over a year?

Ask for the buyer's own numbers, multiply the monthly figure by 12 and compare it with what they use now. For example, R1,850 a month is R22,200 a year, and R1,600 a month is R19,200 a year. Always send the fee schedule so they can check it.

Should I try to close on the first call?

No. Agree to send information and book a set time to talk again. Buyers often take your answer to other people, so a next step that is easy to pass along works better than pressure.

How do I practise these calls without risking a real buyer?

Practise out loud on someone who pushes back, then listen for what to fix first. An AI buyer on a sales call simulator lets a rep repeat the same call many times. Check the lines with the person responsible for compliance in your business before using them live.

What should a sales manager coach first?

Coach one thing at a time, starting with the safety answer and the "check your own policy wording" line. Use a simple scorecard, listen to the call, and give one point to fix before the next practice. Keep checking the wording with the person responsible for compliance in your business.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

See AI sales training

Sources & References

  • https://www.bain.com/insights/the-b2b-elements-of-value-hbr/ - business buyers weigh many elements of value, including personal concerns such as reduced anxiety
  • https://hbr.org/2006/03/customer-value-propositions-in-business-markets - focus on the one or two differences that matter most, against the next best alternative
  • https://www.forrester.com/press-newsroom/forrester-the-state-of-business-buying-2024/ - 13 people involved in a B2B buying decision, 86% of purchases stall
  • https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16719566/ - spacing effect meta-analysis

All legal information verified as of 16 November 2026. Consult with a labour lawyer for specific cases.

Keep reading