1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Why Sales Training Doesn't Stick: How to Fix It
Sales Training· South Africa

Why Sales Training Doesn't Stick: How to Fix It

Why sales training doesn't stick, and what to do the day after: practise out loud on a buyer who pushes back, revisit it weekly, and drill your weakest skill.

··21 min read
Sales trainer gesturing at an objection-handling flowchart on a whiteboard while a colleague role-plays a resistant buyer in a modern open-plan office.

AI-generated

TL;DR: Quick Answer

Why sales training doesn't stick comes down to forgetting: people lose what they never have to recall or use. Fix it by practising out loud the day after against a buyer who pushes back, returning to the material over the following weeks, and spending most practice time on your weakest skill.

  • In a Salesforce survey of 7,775 sales professionals, only 26% said they get one-to-one coaching at least weekly (Salesforce, 2022), so most reps get one burst of training and then nothing.
  • The day after training, spend 20 minutes saying the opening and one objection answer out loud, then do it again every week for a month.
  • Next step: score yourself on the ten-point opening checklist below, find the weakest line, and practise that one first.

Why sales training doesn't stick is not a mystery, and it is rarely the trainer's fault. People forget what they never have to recall. A one-day course hands over a method, and the weeks that follow decide whether anyone uses it. This article uses the six value principles of selling from Mike Steenkamp's method and focuses on the part that stops the forgetting: practise it out loud, with feedback.

If you sell, or you manage people who sell, you can start tomorrow. You will not need a new course. You will need a buyer who pushes back, a few minutes, and a habit of coming back to the same few skills until they are yours. Below is what to do the day after training, how often to return to it, and how to choose what to practise.

Key Takeaways

  • The plan is small: 1 drill the day after training, 4 weeks of short repeats, and 10 opening points to score yourself against (seven of ten is a good opening).
  • Say it out loud to a buyer who pushes back. Reading your notes again feels like learning but does not test whether you can do it on a call.
  • ShiftMate Sim Studio lets a team practise calls out loud on AI buyers built from its own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

Why sales training doesn't stick in the first place

The short answer is that forgetting is the default. Memory researchers have known this for well over a century, and the pattern has been checked again in modern times.

Here is the oldest result in the field, repeated. In 2015, two researchers at the University of Amsterdam replicated the forgetting-curve experiment first done in 1880, and got a similar result.

That study used lists of nonsense syllables, not sales calls, and it was done in Europe. It does not tell you how much of your team's course will be gone by next month. What it does show is the shape of the problem: what you do not use, you lose, and you lose it fast at first. Anyone who has sat through a good course and then found themselves cold calling in the old, familiar way a fortnight later has seen this for themselves.

What a single course does and does not do

Sales training teaches people how to sell: how to reach the person who decides, open a conversation with a stranger, show value the buyer can check, handle objections and agree a next step. A good course gives you a method you can explain in a sentence. That part works on the day.

What a single course cannot do is make the method automatic. Knowing the eight steps and being able to run them while a real buyer interrupts you are different skills. The second one is built by repetition, and a one-off course does not supply the repetition.

Four reasons it fades

When managers ask why sales training fails, the same four causes keep turning up. None of them is about how clever or motivated the team is.

  • Nothing forces recall. Notes go in a folder. Nobody has to pull the method out of their head and use it.
  • Nobody pushes back. Practice among colleagues is polite. Real buyers are not. The first time a rep hears "send me an email" is on a live call.
  • Nobody checks. Without a score or a second pair of ears, a rep cannot tell which skill is slipping.
  • The weak spot is never touched. People practise what they already do well, because it feels good. The skill that costs deals gets left alone.

Each cause has a fix, and the fixes are the rest of this article. They are also the reason sales training retention is a management job, not only a trainer's job. The course is day one. What happens afterwards belongs to the team and the person who leads it.

What should you do the day after sales training?

The day after sales training, say the method out loud to a buyer who pushes back, while it is still fresh. Do it before the inbox and the targets swallow the week.

Twenty minutes is enough. You are not trying to master anything yet. You are making your memory work for the first time, which is the moment the forgetting curve starts to flatten. Reading your notes again does not do that. Speaking does.

The day-after drill, step by step

Copy this card. It works alone, with a colleague, or with an AI buyer.

  1. Pick one real buyer. Choose a person you are actually about to call, and note their role. The role tells you what to lead with: an admin or office buyer cares about Ease and Speed, finance about Price, Safety and Speed, an owner about Price and Volume.
  2. Say your opening out loud, from memory. No script in front of you. Cover who you are, your company, what your company does, what the call is about, how you got their details, what you want, and why it matters to them.
  3. Have the buyer push back. They say the thing real buyers say: "We already have a supplier. Send me an email."
  4. Answer with agree and redirect. Agree with the objection, then redirect to what you do better, and be honest about what switching involves. This is step seven of the method.
  5. Score the opening. Use the checklist below. Write down the one point you missed.
  6. Do it again. Same buyer, same pushback, fixing only that one point.

The checklist is worth reading now, because you will use it for the whole month. A good opening scores seven out of ten. A tough buyer needs eight or nine.

The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)

Who you are 1
Your company 1
What your company does (must be said) 0
What the call is about 2
How you got their details 1
What you want from this call 2
Why it matters to them 3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Notice the weighting. Saying what your company does is worth nothing on its own. It must be said, but it earns no points. Why it matters to the buyer is worth three, more than any other line. When people drill their openings, they spend most of their time on the company description, which earns nothing, and rush the line that earns the most.

Worked example one (made up): the day-after drill

This example is made up. Priya Pillay sells printer paper and stationery for a small supplier called Ridgemont Office Supplies. She finished a one-day course yesterday. This morning she drills with her colleague Grant, who plays a buyer called Mr Naidoo, an office manager.

Priya's opening, from memory:

"Good morning Mr Naidoo, it's Priya Pillay from Ridgemont Office Supplies. We deliver stationery and paper to offices in the area. I'm calling because I found your office on a local business listing, and I'd like to ask whether I may send you a price list and a delivery schedule. The reason it may matter to you is that late or short orders land on your admin team, and that's the time we're trying to take off their plate."

Grant, as Mr Naidoo, pushes back: "We already have a supplier. Send me an email."

Priya's first answer is weak: "Oh, okay, but we're very competitive." Grant stops her there. She tries again:

"That's fair, most offices already have someone, and switching does take some effort, so I wouldn't ask you to move everything. What I can show you is how next-morning delivery would cut the number of times your team chases a late order. Would you be open to looking at it side by side with what you use now, and I'll call you on Thursday at ten?"

Look at what changed. The second answer agrees with the objection, is honest about the effort of switching, leads with Ease and Speed because Mr Naidoo is office staff, and ends on a set time. Priya scores herself eight out of ten on the opening and writes one note: "The 'why it matters' line was good, but I said it last. Move it up." That note is the point of the drill.

The wrong week and the better week

What most teams do after a course What works better
Reread the notes on the weekend Say the opening out loud from memory the next day
Practise on a friendly colleague Practise on a buyer who says "send me an email"
Wait for the next course Return to the same drill every week for a month
Feel good about what you already do well Score the call and fix the one weakest point first

How do you practise it out loud with a buyer who pushes back?

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

ShiftMate is rated 4.5 out of 5 on Google (2,156+ Google reviews)

You practise it by speaking your lines to someone, or something, that answers back the way a real buyer does, and then getting a score or a note on what to fix. Rereading and nodding along does not count.

There are two reasons for the "out loud" part. First, recalling something from memory is what strengthens it. Second, a sentence that reads well on a page often comes out clumsy in the mouth. You only find that out when you say it.

Why the buyer has to push back

Remember the default answer is no. The buyer is thinking "convince me", and until you show that it is good for them, the answer stays no. If your practice partner says "that sounds great, tell me more", you are rehearsing a call that will never happen.

A useful practice buyer does four things:

  • Interrupts the opening with "who is this?" or "what do you want?"
  • Says "we already have someone" and means it.
  • Asks "faster than what?" when you say your service is faster.
  • Tries to end the call with "just send me something".

Those four lines train the four things that matter most in the first minutes: the opening, the objection, the proof and the next step. Our guide to objection handling, with eight answers gives you the agree-and-redirect shape for each, and the sales role play examples page has eight scenarios with scripts you can borrow.

What the research says about simulation

Learning by simulation has been studied well outside sales. One large review looked at classrooms and training rooms rather than call floors, so treat it as support, not proof for your team.

The useful idea is that realistic practice, with feedback, builds complex skills better than being told about them. A sales call is a complex skill: you listen, choose a value principle, answer an objection and steer, all at once. That is why Mike Steenkamp's method says to practise it out loud, with feedback, until it sticks, and why we suggest you practise on AI buyers when a colleague is not free.

Scenario card to copy

Print this and keep it by your desk. It gives you a different pushback each time, so you do not just memorise one answer.

Buyer says Your agree-and-redirect line What good looks like
"We already have a supplier." "That's fair, and switching takes effort. Let me show you where we're quicker, side by side with what you use now." Agrees first, names the cost of switching, compares with their current option
"Send me an email." "Happy to. So that it's useful, which is more important to you, time or cost? And may I call you on Thursday at ten to go through it?" Sends information and agrees a set time to talk again
"You're too expensive." "I understand, price matters. Over a year, here is what the extra effort and delays cost you today." Compares over a year, does not drop the price, does not sell on price alone
"We're not looking right now." "That's fine, most people aren't until something goes wrong. Can I ask what would have to change for you to look?" Gives a real reason to act, never invented urgency

How often should you come back to it over the following weeks?

You should come back to it every week for at least a month, in short sessions, rather than doing one long session and stopping. Spacing the practice out gives your memory repeated chances to be tested just as it begins to fade.

This is not a hunch. The spacing effect is one of the most studied results in learning research. The standard meta-analysis gathered a very large pool of experiments.

Those experiments were mostly done in laboratories, not sales teams, and the details of the best gap vary with how long you need to remember. But the broad point is safe to use: several shorter sessions spread over weeks beat one long cram. This is the heart of sales training reinforcement. A course is not the training. A course plus a month of spaced practice is.

Why a weekly rhythm is rare

Most sales teams do not have this rhythm. It is not that managers do not care; it is that the week fills up. In the survey below, which asked about coaching and not about practice, you can see how rare a weekly habit is. The survey covered sales professionals in many countries, not only South Africa.

If a team lead can find twenty minutes once a week, that puts the team ahead of the pattern. If you manage a call centre, the same slot can sit inside a team huddle. The point is that it happens at the same time every week, so it does not depend on anyone remembering.

Recall first, notes second

When you come back to the material, do not start by opening your notes. Try the opening from memory, then check what you missed. That small order change forces recall, and recall is what makes the memory last. It is also the quickest way to find the weak spot: the line you cannot remember is the line you will fumble on a live call.

Why does sales training fail, and what should you practise most?

Why sales training fails, in most teams, is that people repeat what they are already good at and leave the weak skill alone. You should practise whatever scores lowest, and do it most often.

This feels backwards. Practising your strong opening is pleasant. Practising the objection answer that makes you freeze is not. But the weak spot is where deals are lost, and it is also where one hour of work changes the most.

Find the weakest step

The method has eight steps, in call order. After a few practice calls, ask yourself which step you least want to do, and which one the buyer most often stops you on.

The sales method: eight steps, in call order

  1. Talk to the right person
  2. Earn the right to talk
  3. Remember the default answer is no
  4. Prove value with the six value principles
  5. Show it's safe
  6. Give a real reason to act now
  7. Agree and redirect
  8. Earn the next step
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Typical weak spots are step three, remembering that the default answer is no, because reps talk as if the buyer has already agreed, and step six, giving a real reason to act now, because reps either skip it or invent urgency. Both are easy to find in a recorded practice call and easy to fix with a few repeats.

Use a scorecard so you are not guessing

Without a score, "weakest" is a feeling. Use the opening checklist above, plus the sales call scorecard template, and score every practice call the same way. After three or four calls, the lowest line is obvious.

Skill What good looks like Weak sign
Opening Seven of ten or better; the "why it matters to you" line is said early Long description of your company, no reason for the buyer
Proof of value One or two principles, compared with what the buyer uses now, with a number or example "We're faster" with no "faster than what?" answer
Objection Agrees first, then redirects, honest about switching Argues, or drops the price at once
Next step Information sent and a set time agreed to talk again "I'll send something and be in touch"

Worked example two (made up): practise the weak spot

This example is made up. Karin Botha sells rooftop solar installations to small businesses for a company called Bokveld Energy Partners. After a course, she scores her practice calls and sees a pattern: she opens well, then leads every call with price.

In solar and energy, the weights in Mike Steenkamp's method are Safety 3, Quality 1, Ease 1, Speed 1, Volume 0 and Price 4 out of ten. Price is the biggest, but Safety is close behind, and Karin never mentions it.

Solar and energy: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)

Safety 3
Quality 1
Ease 1
Speed 1
Volume 0
Price 4
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide, by Mike Steenkamp.

Her practice plan for the next three weeks is to drill one line only: showing the system is at least as safe as what the buyer uses now. She writes it as: "Before we talk about the saving, let me explain how the installation is checked and signed off, so you know it is at least as safe as your current supply."

Then she brings price back, but compares it over a year. In her made-up numbers, the monthly electricity bill falls by R1,200, which is R14,400 over twelve months. She says: "Over a year, that is R14,400 off your bill. Does that look right for your business?" She never sells on price alone, because cheaper does not mean better.

The key move is not clever wording. It is that Karin chose the weakest, highest-value skill and kept repeating it. By week three, the safety line stops being a thing she has to think about.

A note for safety-gate industries

In financial services, insurance, healthcare and software, safety is a gate: nothing else counts until the buyer is sure it is at least as safe as what they have now. If you sell into these industries, the safety line is almost always the one to practise first. What you may and may not say in these industries is a matter for the person responsible for compliance in your business, so check what applies with them before you finalise your wording.

What fixes why sales training doesn't stick? A four-week plan

The fix for why sales training doesn't stick is a short, repeated habit: one drill the day after, then four weekly sessions, each aimed at the lowest score. Here is a plan you can start with.

The plan assumes you have already had a course or read the guide. It costs nothing but time.

When What to do (20 minutes) What good looks like
Day after training Run the day-after drill with one real buyer and one pushback Opening scored, one missed point written down
End of week one Opening from memory, then a different objection from the scenario card Opening score up by at least a point
Week two Drill the lowest-scoring step only; swap in a new buyer role The weak line comes out without notes
Week three Full call: opening, value, objection, why now and next step A set time agreed to talk again
Week four Repeat the day-after drill and compare your score Seven of ten or more, eight or nine for a tough buyer

If you manage a team

Make the weekly session fixed, short and visible. Put it in the diary at the same time each week. Ask each person for one score and one line they will fix. Do not turn it into a performance review, or people will hide their weak spots.

Consider what a course costs. Take a made-up team of eight reps and a one-day course at R3,500 a head: that is R28,000. If nothing follows it, you have paid R28,000 for a day's memory. Twenty minutes a week for a month costs far less than that in time, and it is what makes the R28,000 count. You can also read more about AI sales training for teams if you want practice to run without you in the room.

If you are a solo seller or small-business owner

You do not need a team. Record yourself on your phone, say the opening and one objection answer out loud, play it back and score it. It is awkward the first time. It is also the quickest way to hear what a buyer hears. Put it in your diary for Friday afternoon, when the week is winding down and the calls are fresh.

If you cold call, the cold calling tips that work in South Africa pair well with this plan, and the telesales script examples give you openings to practise.

What this does not solve: why sales training doesn't stick is not only about memory

Practice fixes forgetting. It does not fix everything that makes a sales team struggle, and it is better to say so plainly.

  • A weak offer. If your product is not safer, better, easier, faster, bigger in volume or cheaper in any way that the buyer can check, no amount of practice will save the call.
  • The wrong buyer. Step one is talking to the right person. A perfect opening to someone who does not decide still ends with no.
  • Real calls are harder than practice calls. A simulated buyer, whether a colleague or an AI, is not a real one. Practice makes you ready, but it does not replace a manager listening to real calls.
  • Time. If the week has no room for twenty minutes, the plan will not run. The fix there is a diary decision by a manager, not more motivation.
  • Evidence limits. The studies cited here are mostly from the United States or Europe, and some come from classrooms and laboratories, not sales teams. Use them as direction, not as a promise of a result for your team.

One more caution: do not use this to turn every session into a test. People who feel judged stop practising. Keep it short, keep it kind and keep it regular.

How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help

ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer. Every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first, which makes the weekly habit easy to run. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. If you want to see the practice side, start with the sales call simulator.

Frequently asked questions

Why doesn't sales training stick?

Why sales training doesn't stick is mostly about forgetting. Memory fades quickly unless people have to recall and use what they learned. A single course gives knowledge, but nobody practises out loud, nobody pushes back and nobody comes back to it. Practice in the days and weeks after the course is what keeps it.

What should I do the day after sales training?

Say your opening out loud, from memory, to a buyer who pushes back, and score it against the ten-point opening checklist. Write down the one point you missed and do it again, fixing only that. Twenty minutes is enough. Do not reread your notes instead, because that does not test whether you can do it on a call.

How often should a team practise after training?

Weekly for at least a month works well, in short sessions of about twenty minutes. Spread-out practice beats one long session because your memory is tested just as it starts to fade. Keep it at the same time each week so it does not depend on anyone remembering, and focus each session on the lowest-scoring skill.

What should I practise first?

Practise whatever scores lowest, not what you are already good at. For most sellers that is the objection answer, the reason to act now, or the line that explains why the call matters to the buyer. If you sell in financial services, insurance, healthcare or software, start with showing it is safe, because safety is a gate there.

How do I practise handling a buyer who pushes back?

Have someone say the lines real buyers say, such as "we already have a supplier" or "send me an email". Answer by agreeing first, then redirecting to what you do better, and be honest about what switching involves. Then agree a next step. You can do this with a colleague, a recorded phone call, or an AI buyer.

Is a refresher course better than short weekly practice?

For keeping skills, short weekly practice usually does more than a refresher day, because it gives repeated recall over time. A refresher can still help when the method itself has changed or new people join. The best set-up is a course to teach the method and weekly practice to make it automatic.

How can a sales manager tell if training has stuck?

Score each practice call and each recorded real call the same way, using the opening checklist and a call scorecard. If scores rise over four weeks and the weakest line improves, it has stuck. If scores fall back to where they started, the training is fading and the team needs more regular practice.

ShiftMate Sim Studio

Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no

Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.

See AI sales training

Sources & References

  • https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16719566/ - spacing effect meta-analysis (Cepeda et al., 2006)
  • https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0120644 - replication of the forgetting curve (Murre and Dros, 2015)
  • https://www.salesforce.com/news/stories/sales-research-2023/ - share of sales professionals receiving weekly one-to-one coaching
  • https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.3102/0034654320933544 - simulation-based learning meta-analysis (Chernikova et al., 2020)

All legal information verified as of 16 November 2026. Consult with a labour lawyer for specific cases.

Keep reading