TL;DR: Quick Answer
A sales interview role play is a five-minute practice call between a candidate and a colleague playing the buyer. Use one made-up scenario and one buyer brief for every candidate, score only what was said, such as the opening, a question before pitching, value with a number and a next step, and let a person decide.
Run it after the first conversation and before the final interview, with a five-minute call and a scorecard of four marks, such as a 7-out-of-10 opening.
Never mark accent, polish or nerves. Mark what the candidate said, and write down the exact words.
Copy the scenario, buyer brief and scorecard below, then practise the same call yourself on AI buyers with the sales call simulator.
A sales interview role play is the part of hiring where you stop asking people how they would sell and let them do it for five minutes. It is the most useful single step in how to hire salespeople , because a polished talker and a good seller are often two different people. The call is built on the method in the six value principles sales training guide , and the step it tests is the opening and the first question, taught in the guide under practise out loud .
This article gives you a copy-and-use kit: one scenario, one buyer brief, one scorecard and a simple rule for who decides. Everything here is for a founder, a sales manager or a contact-centre team leader who has to choose between candidates and wants the choice to rest on something they all did, not on a feeling.
Key Takeaways
Give every candidate the same scenario card and the same buyer brief, and keep the call to five minutes. A made-up office-supplies example below uses R3,600 a month against R3,200, which is R4,800 over a year.
Score four things that can be heard: the opening, a question before pitching, value with a number and a next step. Do not score accent, polish or nerves.
Use the same kind of practice call in your own team. ShiftMate Sim Studio lets a sales team practise calls out loud on AI buyers, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.
What is a sales interview role play, and where does it fit?
A sales interview role play is a short, scripted practice call in which a candidate sells to a colleague who plays a buyer. The candidate gets a scenario card a few minutes before. The colleague has a buyer brief. Both follow the same rules for every candidate, and a scorecard records what was said.
It sits in the middle of your process. Many managers run it like this:
First conversation. A short chat about experience, the products they have sold and why they want this role. This is where your usual sales interview questions belong.
The practice call. Five minutes of selling, plus five minutes of scoring. This is the sales interview exercise .
Final interview. A longer conversation with the person who will manage them, which can start from what you heard on the call.
Put it after the first conversation, not before, so you only use a colleague's time on people you already want to see. Put it before the final interview, so that conversation can be about real evidence: "You asked about their current supplier first. Why did you choose that?"
What the sales role play interview shows that questions do not
Most sales interview questions ask for a story: "Tell me about a deal you won." A good story is easy to practise and hard to check. A call cannot be rehearsed in the same way, because the buyer answers in real time, and what the candidate does next is the evidence.
A sales role play interview also shows you things a conversation hides:
Whether they open with who they are, who they work for and why the buyer should care, or just launch into the product.
Whether they ask a question before they pitch.
Whether they can put a number on a benefit.
Whether they ask for a next step, or end with "so, let me know."
These are the same skills a new rep needs in their first week. If you want to see how a good opening is built, the cold call script with five fill-in openings shows the pattern, and the guide's step earn the right to talk explains why each part is there.
How do you set up a sales interview role play so it is the same for every candidate?
You make four things identical for everyone: the scenario card, the buyer brief, the length of the call and the scorecard. If any one of them changes between candidates, you are no longer comparing like with like. You are comparing luck.
Use this checklist before the first candidate arrives:
One scenario card. The same one-page card, handed over at the same time, for example ten minutes before the call.
One buyer brief. The same brief given to your colleague, who plays the buyer in the same mood every time.
One length. Five minutes by a visible clock. When the time is up, the call ends, even if it was going well.
One scorecard. The same marks, in the same order, filled in during the call and not afterwards from memory.
One buyer. Where you can, the same colleague plays the buyer for every candidate. If you cannot, give each of them the same brief and a read-through beforehand.
One scorer who is not the buyer. The buyer is busy responding. A second person listens and ticks the scorecard.
Tell candidates the rules up front, in plain words. For example: "This is a five-minute call. You will sell to a made-up buyer, using a card I will give you. We are not marking your accent or whether you are nervous. We are listening for what you say. Do you have any questions before we start?"
If a candidate needs something changed so they can take part, for instance a quieter room or the card on paper, talk to them about it before the call and give them what helps. If you record the call or keep notes, check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business.
Why one scenario and not a choice of three
It is tempting to let candidates pick the product they know best. Resist it. A candidate who sells fuel cards all day will look better against a buyer who buys fuel cards. The point is to learn how each person behaves when something is new, so the scenario must be the same for all.
It also keeps your marking honest. One scenario means you know exactly what a good answer sounds like, because you wrote it. This lines up with a point made by Anderson, Narus and van Rossum in "Customer Value Propositions in Business Markets" (Harvard Business Review, 2006): value propositions that list every benefit are weaker than ones that focus on the one or two differences that matter most to the customer, shown against the customer's next best alternative and backed with evidence. A single, clear scenario lets you check for exactly that.
The scenario card and the buyer brief to copy
Below is a complete kit for a made-up office-supplies seller. It is invented, so change the product and the numbers to suit your own business, but keep the shape. Every detail the candidate needs is on the card, because you are testing how they sell and not whether they can guess your product.
The scenario card (give this to the candidate)
Label: Made up. Kameel Office Supplies and Vermeulen & Pillay Accounting do not exist.
Item
What the candidate is told
You work for Kameel Office Supplies. You deliver paper, toner, stationery and cleaning supplies to small offices.
You are calling Karin Botha, the office manager at Vermeulen & Pillay Accounting, a 12-person firm. You found her name and number on the firm's website.
What you offer Orders placed before 14:00 arrive the next working day. Minimum order R1,500. A typical 12-person office spends about R3,200 a month with Kameel.
What you know The firm has an existing supplier. You do not know which one, or how much they pay.
Your aim This is a first call. You are not closing a sale. Your aim is a next step: a date and time to talk again, and something sent beforehand.
Time Five minutes. Begin when you are ready.
Notice what the card does and does not say. It gives the candidate their own company, the buyer's role, how they got the details and the facts they can use for a number. It does not give them a script. What they do with the card is the test.
The buyer brief (give this to your colleague)
Label: Made up. The buyer plays Karin Botha. Read this out loud once before the first candidate, then keep to it every time.
Who you are. Karin Botha, office manager. Busy, polite, not rude. You are mid-task when the phone rings.
Your default answer is no. You are thinking "convince me." You will not say yes to anything on a first call.
Your situation. You pay your current supplier about R3,600 a month. Deliveries take three to four working days, and twice this year the printer ran out of toner before the order arrived. You do not volunteer this. You say it only if the candidate asks a good question.
What matters to you. Fewer hassles and orders that arrive when you need them. The firm's owner worries about cost, but you do not decide on price alone.
Your first reply. If the opening is weak, say "I'm quite busy, what is this about?" If the opening is clear and says why it matters to you, say "Okay, go on."
One objection to use, once. "We're happy with our current supplier." Do not argue. If the candidate agrees and redirects honestly, soften slightly.
The next step. If the candidate asks for a specific time to talk again and offers to send something first, agree. If they say "I'll call you sometime," say "Send me an email."
What you never do. Never help the candidate. Never invent new objections. Never change your mood between candidates.
Because the buyer is an office manager, the brief points toward ease and speed, which is the guide's advice for admin and office staff. The next section shows the role map, so you can swap the buyer for a different role.
What to lead with, by the buyer's role
Buyer's role Lead with Admin and office staff Ease, Speed Finance Price, Safety, Speed Owner Price, Volume Marketing and sales Volume, Quality Operations Speed, Ease, Quality Procurement Price, Quality
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
To change the scenario for another role, such as a finance buyer or an owner, use the chart above to decide what the candidate should lead with, and rewrite the brief to match. Keep the same structure and the same length. For an office-supplies seller, the weight of each reason to buy looks like this:
Office supplies: how much each reason to buy counts (out of 10)
Safety
1
Quality
1
Ease
3
Speed
2
Volume
0
Price
3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
How do you run the five-minute call?
You run it like a real call with a clock on it: the candidate reads the card, the colleague plays the buyer, a second person scores, and when five minutes are up the call stops. Nobody coaches during the call. Feedback comes afterwards, if at all.
A simple running order for each candidate, about fifteen minutes in total:
Hand over the card and give the candidate five to ten minutes to read it and think.
Read the rules aloud, including that you are not marking accent or nerves.
Start the call. The buyer answers the phone. The clock runs for five minutes.
Score during the call. Write the exact words next to each mark. Do not wait.
End on time. Thank them. Do not tell them how they did.
Optional two-minute debrief. Ask: "What would you do differently?" How a person reflects on their own call is useful information.
What a strong call sounds like
This example is made up. It is the kind of call you are hoping to hear. The candidate, Sarah, is calling for Kameel Office Supplies.
Sarah: "Good morning, Karin, it's Sarah from Kameel Office Supplies. We deliver paper, toner and stationery to small offices. I found your details on your firm's website. I'm calling to ask two questions about how you order supplies, and to see if a quick chat next week is worth your time. It matters because offices your size often lose a few hours a month chasing late deliveries. Is now an okay time for two minutes?"
Karin: "Okay, go on."
Sarah: "Thanks. How long does it take for an order to reach you at the moment?"
Karin: "Three or four days, usually."
Sarah: "And has that ever left you without toner, or paper, when you needed it?"
Karin: "Twice this year, actually."
Sarah: "That's the thing we fix. Orders placed before 14:00 reach you the next working day, so instead of waiting three or four days, you wait one. For an office your size we usually see around R3,200 a month, and I'd like to compare that with what you pay now, if you're open to it."
Karin: "We're happy with our current supplier."
Sarah: "That's fair, and I wouldn't want you to change if it's working. If the only issue is the late toner, it may be worth seeing whether next-day delivery fixes it. Switching does mean setting up a new account, which takes about fifteen minutes. Could I send you our price list today and phone you again on Thursday at ten to talk it through?"
Sarah opened with who she is, her company, what it does, how she got the details, what she wants and why it matters. She asked a question before pitching. She gave a number, one day against three or four. She agreed with the objection, redirected honestly and asked for a specific next step. That is what you are marking.
What a weak call sounds like
Another made-up example, with a candidate named Grant. It is not mean to Grant. It is simply a call you would score low.
Grant: "Hi, is that Karin? We sell office supplies at very competitive prices. We've got paper, toner, pens, everything. Are you looking for a new supplier?"
Karin: "I'm quite busy, what is this about?"
Grant: "Well, we're cheaper than most, and our service is great. I can send you a catalogue. Let me know if you're interested."
Grant has not said who he works for, how he got her details or why it matters to her. He has asked no question, given no number and agreed no time. His tone may be friendly, which is a good sign about him as a person, but the call gives you nothing to hire on yet. The scorecard makes that visible without anyone having to say "I just didn't feel it."
How do you score a sales role play interview fairly?
You score a sales role play interview on what was said, using the same four marks for everyone, and you write down the words that earned each mark. A mark without a quote is an opinion. A mark with a quote is evidence you can show another person.
The four marks follow the method in the guide. The first is the opening, which the guide teaches under earn the right to talk . Here is how the opening is worth 10 points, from the method:
The opening checklist: what each part is worth (out of 10)
Who you are
1
Your company
1
What your company does (must be said)
0
What the call is about
2
How you got their details
1
What you want from this call
2
Why it matters to them
3
Source: ShiftMate sales training guide , by Mike Steenkamp.
Seven out of ten is a good opening. A tough buyer needs eight or nine. Notice that "what your company does" earns nothing on its own. It must be said, but it is the "why it matters to them" part, worth three points, that moves the call forward.
The scorecard to copy
Mark
What good looks like
Write down
1. The opening Scores 7 or more out of 10 on the opening checklist. The exact opening line and the score.
2. A question before pitching Asks at least one question about the buyer's current situation before describing the product. The question, word for word.
3. Value with a number Names one reason to buy and backs it with a figure from the card, compared with what the buyer uses now. The sentence with the number.
4. A next step Asks for a specific time to talk again and offers something to send beforehand. The words used to ask, and the time agreed.
Give each mark one of three results: clear (it happened as described), partly (it happened but was vague) or missing (it did not happen). For the opening, record the score out of 10. That is all you need. If you want a longer version, the sales call scorecard template covers a full call.
What you never mark
This is the part that makes the exercise fair, so say it to candidates and say it to your scorers. Do not mark:
Accent. South African callers speak English, Afrikaans, isiZulu, Sesotho and many other first languages, and a buyer does not buy from an accent. They buy from a reason.
Polish. A smooth delivery can hide a weak call, and a plain delivery can hide a strong one. Mark the content.
Nerves. Everyone is nervous on a role play. A shaky voice that still asks a good question beats a calm voice that asks none.
Confidence of tone, humour or small talk. They are nice to have, and they are not on the scorecard.
Knowledge of your product. The card gives them what they need. You are not testing memory.
A simple test for each mark: "Could another person, reading only my notes, see why I gave this?" If the answer is no, the mark is not ready.
Who decides, and how do you use the score?
A person decides, not the scorecard. The scorecard is evidence that goes into the decision alongside the first conversation, the final interview and whatever else you use. It tells you what happened on the call. It does not tell you who to hire.
Here is a straightforward way to use it:
Collect the cards. Put the scorecards for every candidate side by side after all the calls are done, not one at a time.
Read the quotes first. Before you look at any totals, read the words written down for each mark.
Look for the pattern. A candidate who missed the next step but asked excellent questions is trainable. A candidate who skipped the opening and the questions and pitched at once is a different case.
Bring it to the final interview. Use the call as the starting point. "You asked about delivery time first. How did you know to do that?"
Let the hiring manager decide and write one sentence of reasoning that refers to the evidence.
The reason to keep a person in charge is simple. Five minutes is a small sample, and a scorecard counts only what you decided to count. People are more than four marks. The scorecard keeps the decision tied to something everyone did, which is a lot better than a feeling after a friendly chat.
Why this matters more than it seems
Getting a hire wrong is expensive in time as much as money. The Bridge Group's 2026 study of 158 B2B companies, mostly in North America, found that account executives took 6.2 months to reach full productivity and that 48% of reps were at quota. It is not a South African figure, and the study is about account executives, not every sales role. Still, it shows how long a new seller can take to become productive, and how much a small, early signal can be worth.
A practice call will not tell you who will be great. It will help you avoid the avoidable mistakes, such as hiring a good talker who never asks a question. For a longer view of what happens once someone starts, see the new sales rep 30-day plan .
What this does not solve
A five-minute sales interview role play does not tell you everything about a candidate, and it is worth being honest about what it leaves out.
It is a small sample. One call, one buyer, one product. A candidate may have a bad day, or a great one.
It does not show long sales cycles. It will not tell you whether they can follow up for three months, manage a deal across several decision-makers or keep a pipeline tidy.
It does not measure how someone handles a hard day. Rejection builds up over weeks, and a practice call cannot show that.
The colleague playing the buyer matters. A buyer who is too easy or too harsh will distort the result. Practise the brief, and have the same person play the buyer each time.
It is not a replacement for references or for the conversation. It adds one kind of evidence. It does not replace the others.
It tests the opening more than the whole method. The guide has eight steps, and five minutes only reaches the first few. It will not show how someone handles a long objection or a safety question in a high-stakes industry.
If your product is in financial services, insurance, healthcare or software, the buyer will want to know it is safe before anything else counts, so you may want a second scenario that tests that. If your business sells into one of those fields, check what applies with the person responsible for compliance in your business before you design the call.
Finally, the call does not fix a weak team around the new hire. Only 26% of sales professionals in a 2022 Salesforce survey of 7,775 said they get one-to-one coaching at least weekly. That is a survey from many countries, not a South African one, but it is a reminder that hiring well is half of the job and coaching is the other half. The article on sales coaching tips for managers picks up where this one stops.
Practise the call before you run it
The weakest part of most interview role plays is the colleague playing the buyer. They have not rehearsed, so they go easy on one candidate and hard on the next. The fix is to practise the buyer role, and to practise the selling side yourself, so you know what a good call feels like.
Some ways to prepare:
Play the buyer with a friend first. Read the brief out loud and run the call twice, so the lines come naturally.
Sell the scenario yourself. Use the card, set a timer and see how much of the scorecard you can tick. You will learn which marks are hard to reach in five minutes.
Use an AI buyer. You can practise on AI buyers in the sales call simulator , which is a good way to hear what a tough buyer sounds like before you play one.
Look at more scenarios. The sales role play examples page has eight scenarios with scripts, and you can borrow the shape of any of them.
The reason to practise it at all is that skills fade fast without repetition. For ideas on spacing practice out so it sticks, read how to practise sales calls so it sticks . The same applies to you as the scorer: the more calls you hear, the better your marking gets.
How ShiftMate and ShiftMate Sim Studio help
ShiftMate Sim Studio is where a sales team practises calls out loud on AI buyers built from the company's own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first. ShiftMate is the South African marketplace where businesses hire call centre agents who have already been assessed. The practice call in this article is your own exercise, run by your own people with your own scorecard, and ShiftMate does not run it for you.
Frequently asked questions
What is a sales interview role play?
A sales interview role play is a short practice call in which a candidate sells to a colleague who plays a buyer. Each candidate gets the same scenario card and the same buyer brief, and the call lasts about five minutes. A scorecard records what was said, so the choice rests on evidence.
How long should a sales role play interview last?
Five minutes for the call is enough to hear an opening, a question, a number and a next step. Allow five to ten minutes beforehand for the candidate to read the scenario card, and a few minutes afterwards to finish the scorecard. Keep the length the same for every candidate.
Where does the role play fit in how to hire salespeople?
Put it after the first conversation and before the final interview. The first conversation covers experience and your usual sales interview questions. The practice call then gives you something to talk about at the final interview, which means the last conversation is based on what the candidate actually did.
What should I mark on a sales interview exercise?
Mark four things that can be heard: the opening, a question before pitching, value backed with a number and a next step. Write down the exact words next to each mark. Do not mark accent, polish or nerves, because none of them tells you whether the person can sell.
Should every candidate get the same scenario?
Yes. One scenario and one buyer brief for everyone lets you compare like with like. If candidates choose their own product or meet a buyer in a different mood, you end up comparing luck. Keep the card, the brief, the clock and the scorecard identical for every person.
Who should play the buyer?
A colleague who has read the buyer brief and practised it, ideally the same person for every candidate. They stay polite, say no by default, reveal their situation only when asked a good question, and never help the candidate. A second person should listen and fill in the scorecard.
Can the scorecard decide who I hire?
No. The scorecard is one piece of evidence that sits beside the first conversation, the final interview and your own judgement. A person makes the decision and writes one sentence of reasoning that points to what was said on the call. The scorecard keeps that reasoning honest.
Do I need to be a sales expert to run one?
No, but you should practise it first. Sell the scenario yourself with a timer, play the buyer with a colleague and use the scorecard on both. Reading the sales training guide helps you recognise a good opening. Check any recording or note-keeping with the person responsible for compliance in your business.
ShiftMate Sim Studio
Practise this on an AI buyer who starts at no
Your team practises sales calls out loud on AI buyers built from your own offer, and every practice call gets a report with one thing to fix first.
See AI sales training